• Welcome to "The New" Wrestling Smarks Forum!

    I see that you are not currently registered on our forum. It only takes a second, and you can even login with your Facebook! If you would like to register now, pease click here: Register

    Once registered please introduce yourself in our introduction thread which can be found here: Introduction Board


"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

Poyser

Pathological Liar
For me asking questions to various people which up to this point Abi has been doing to this point. He has been on Jeff some but it didn't feel like he was just asking to get people angry or upset to create chaos.

In my experience some scum ask multiple questions to make others angry and start to react on emotion. I didn't get that from readings Abi's posts. Still behind some.

@Ekkologix I will update my reads after I finish reading. You asked for my reads 2 posts back.

Sent from my SM-S908U using Tapatalk
:pogba my reply there was me asking what your definition of aggressive was in a mafia sense, because you said sister abigail wasn’t being aggressive but then described what I’d consider aggressive play. Here you’re acting as though you said he was aggressive lmaoo

or am I misunderstanding your point??
 

Sister Abigail

Well-Known Member
Baldy Needs A Toupee

So Baldy's first four posts into this game is pretty fluffy. I know that doesn't mean a lot, but Baldy said they had a lot of experience, so I guess I'd be hoping from something a bit more from a player with that experience. When Poyser calls him out on it, he just claims its his playstyle.

Welcome to my play style :)

Again, I would hope an experienced player wouldn't be this casual.

Posts 129 and 133 some early talk about how votes are in the wrong direction but gives no correction on where they should go or what their reads are. Post 149 Tweet calls Baldy out on not liking votes and asks for clarification but gets nothing in return. Not liking this at all.]

Posts 147 and 167 are posts I don't like because Baldy purposely draws attention to how they're 'fine' with having votes on them. This seems forced to me.

For what it's worth I think you are town.

The lack of any kind of followinv votes on me or the others with votes leads me to think the scum are laying low at the moment, so the more active guys are looking better to me.

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

I hate this post. Poyser calls Baldrick scum and Baldrick then gives Poyser a Town read. Just feels wrong.

@Tommy Bedlam @Worst Player Ever you pair have anything to add?

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

This is a weird callout. Why asking these two in particular? He says it's because he hasn't seen them post, but there were a few players like that at the time.

Makes me wonder as well considering I think Tommy is a bit Wolfy.

Hmm ok, so @Sister Abigail what makes me make your list?

I do feel a little bit sketchy of Mando now, something isn't sitting quite right there at the moment.

I'm 50/50 on RD's claim. I'd expect him to be kept alive purely because it's the easy lynch the next day. Numbers wise it's a small percentage of hitting a mafia aligned member at this early stage.

Not sure what to make of Ace M at the moment, probably more down to the fact of being the first game here rather than anything else.

Did suss Mando. Take that for what you will.

Well that took far longer than expected....but some vieww from that hundreds of posts i've just been through.

I'm on the fence with Man, something feels off but I can't put my finger on if it's a good thing or a bad thing.

Ekko has put a lot out there, now i'm not sure if that is for information overload or being a genuine attempt at getting a proper feel for things.

Wang i'll give the benefit of the doubt to for now.

Tweet....there's something nagging there but not enough to put a vote down.

Holt...i'm ok with for now, something will no doubt coke from that one way or the other as we move forward.

I'm not liking that there's still a few we haven't really had input from. Are we focussing too much on the contributions so far and not enough of those laying low?

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

This reads list seems forced and like he just picked names out of a hat. Doesn't even lean too hard one way or another on any of these players. Feels terrible.

Shoot me, go for it. Will give you nothing other than looking at the few who have been after me from the get go.

Unlike Man, my role can be proved straight away but I am not giving any of you the satisfaction of that.

Lynch me, kill me do whatever. I am town, my flip will be town and you'd have just lost a number.

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

Appeal to emotion? I guess he can prove his role. Heard Governor or Duelist tossed around. Doesn't mean those are Town roles.
 

Sister Abigail

Well-Known Member
Coasting???

like suss me for anything but coasting

super deep coming for the person that most relevant contribution to the game was pressure voting a desperado claim
You're here, you're active, but I don't remember any of significance from you. You just came out of the Championship Game, so I expect you to be good. You've done enough to be present and making sure people know you're here, but I just don't think I've vibed with anything you've said.
 

Sister Abigail

Well-Known Member
<3

like is would be hard to post that much and coast.

but then we have sister Abigail with almost 180 and not saying much, so maybe I think highly of my ability
Do you think I've done nothing? Do you not think I've asked questions, and presented my thoughts, tried to use my vote as a tool? I'm sorry I'm not Town leader in this game, but I assure you I am trying to put the pieces together for myself.
 

Sister Abigail

Well-Known Member
Going on about how even if Jeff shoots mafia then he could still be indy lol

also baldy has confirmed he is a duelist fwiw
Hmmm. Yeah not a great look to try and still place some doubt around Jeff even if he shot scum, but also could just be him being weary of an Indie like that in the game; it wouldn't be the first time I saw someone claim Vig as an Indie. Oneiros has also done enough other stuff that I feel alright with him right now. I think there were some questions about Jeff's claim, how his misread it, and how he handled the shot, that calling him a possible Indie isn't the most damning thing.

Is Dueliest always Town, though?
 

Canadian Dragon

The Ace of WS
Hmmm. Yeah not a great look to try and still place some doubt around Jeff even if he shot scum, but also could just be him being weary of an Indie like that in the game; it wouldn't be the first time I saw someone claim Vig as an Indie. Oneiros has also done enough other stuff that I feel alright with him right now. I think there were some questions about Jeff's claim, how his misread it, and how he handled the shot, that calling him a possible Indie isn't the most damning thing.

Is Dueliest always Town, though?
absolutely 50 50 here
 

Ace Marvel

KPOP Innocent Child
Do you think I've done nothing? Do you not think I've asked questions, and presented my thoughts, tried to use my vote as a tool? I'm sorry I'm not Town leader in this game, but I assure you I am trying to put the pieces together for myself.
In a nutshell yes

you have use like 20 post to say you ask people question and that that is towny and yada yada. And the after all the info you gather, you present the most uninspired reads I have seen so far.
 

Oneiros

Member
Is it feasible to still lynch someone this day phase? We should aim for it imo.

I'll read back on the leading wagons, Tweet and Baldrick, and make my decision.
 

Poyser

Pathological Liar
Hmmm. Yeah not a great look to try and still place some doubt around Jeff even if he shot scum, but also could just be him being weary of an Indie like that in the game; it wouldn't be the first time I saw someone claim Vig as an Indie. Oneiros has also done enough other stuff that I feel alright with him right now. I think there were some questions about Jeff's claim, how his misread it, and how he handled the shot, that calling him a possible Indie isn't the most damning thing.

Is Dueliest always Town, though?
Nah I’ve seen it be both town/scum and even indy plenty of times lol
 

Bobby Barrows

Trans Rights
Vote Count:

Baldrick (4) - Poyser, Jeff, SA, Ace Marvel
Mandalorian (1) - Tommy
Tweet (5) - CP, Smark, Man, Lethal, Ekko
Smark (1) - Oneiros


53 Minutes Left
 
Top