AEW Dynamite Mafia Game Thread

[Alco]

Doddsy's a master in avoiding lynches btw, let's keep that in mind.

I'm kind of annoyed we're basically at the same point we were yesterday. Not sure I buy the entire Lethal defense there, to be honest. Especially if you factor in what Haza said, about there being 3 vote-related roles (1 of which has flipped already).

How much time is left?

 

[Odo]

Hey guys, after today’s over, I’ll be around for the weekend, this is what I was worried about lol

I don’t thinI I’ve ever seen a post like that from TKOK

 

[Odo]

I’m not really sold on Doddsys claim tbh - it would imply town have a BG/Jk also which seems overkill in a game this size. Could be a smart way of claiming rolestopper or some such role

 

[Poyser]

:

Considering I missed the first few hours of the game and tried to catch up, I don’t think posting the PGO hint right before night is at all a bad thing? If anything it’s when there was likely to more activity?

Why would I draw suspicion over a claim that I’ve played enough to know doesn’t have a long shelf life when it comes to POE?

Claiming PGO is infinitely less believable the later it comes. If you’re gonna soft it or whatever then standard practise is to do it in your first post, because that helps you in PoE for obvious reasons. What exactly is your experience with PGOs so far?

 

[Poyser]

Where did I say that the claim was the main reason? You’re twisting my post to fit your read here pal.

I link all points and then expand on the vote.

Lethal on play, someone I’ve been spot on about a few times before, felt town. The claim mistake is a whole bunch of WIFOM that needs clearing up. The unvote / wagon derailment was more than enough to sway from feeling he is town off play to potentially scum.

I miss the part where you go from thinking he’s town on play to wanting to lynch him 20 mins in to day? Doesn’t really track pal lol

 

[Poyser]

it makes lethal look better because calling BG Faith Healer for no reason is similar to calling Actor a Compulsive Actor for no reason lol

Faith healer is slightly different to BG btw

Could potentially be a BG in the game as well as they tend to work against each other.

 

[Poyser]

In which case it makes a pretty cute fake as it could still be a town role if a bg cc comes in. But then if that was the case I'd have expected you to be up front about the restriction as using it as defense later would be suspect as fuck lol

I think withholding the restriction is more towny

So thats good!

Ye also I don’t think he’d have just said he was the BG in the original claim? Idk tho that part is wifom

 

[Poyser]

I’m not really sold on Doddsys claim tbh - it would imply town have a BG/Jk also which seems overkill in a game this size. Could be a smart way of claiming rolestopper or some such role

Well, the BG could be scum tbf

 

[Alco]

Who do you think has the better chances of lying here, Odo? Doddsy or Evans? Or Lethal even?

 

[Odo]

Well, the BG could be scum tbf

I mean I guess, but that seems to be more like a Barry design than a Jeff one lol

 

[Poyser]

I mean I guess, but that seems to be more like a Barry design than a Jeff one lol

Jeff has only hosted one game before tho right? And his proposed setup was pretty heavy I think before I suggested some tweaks. Has anybody checked over this one?

I still think I’m believing Doddsy tbh, but the faith healer instead of BG claim has definitely raised some doubts. Would kinda wanna see more from Doddsy at this point tho than calling his wagon shit

 

[Odo]

Who do you think has the better chances of lying here, Odo? Doddsy or Evans? Or Lethal even?

The only one I think could be lying about their claim is Doddsy - Lethal is probably an actor and Evans is probably a PGO

@Hank are you the kind that passively activates, or do you need to submit the usage as an action?

 

[Odo]

Jeff has only hosted one game before tho right? And his proposed setup was pretty heavy I think before I suggested some tweaks. Has anybody checked over this one?

I still think I’m believing Doddsy tbh, but the faith healer instead of BG claim has definitely raised some doubts. Would kinda wanna see more from Doddsy at this point tho than calling his wagon shit

I fucking hate suspecting Doddsy when he’s scum because he’s hard to pin down - his defences are usually convincing and the timezone thing is a factor too

FTR Jeff thought town were too strong at one point in my game and 2 protection roles would be above and beyond - the augmenter is a role I invented that he gave to Phenom so this was created after that game had finished. Pretty sure it wasn’t checked tho

 

[Lethal]

iirc he had Curry give it a glance

 

[Lethal]

You get why we can’t just take your word for the fact that the mod fucked up your role pm right?

Of course, but I'm being 100% transparent with it. Jeff can't exactly confirm me in the thread now can he