Seth MacFarlane Mafia Game Thread

[Sky]

I like this Jeff, not giving a town read to OMB for his claim, because his claim is shit

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Odo being a double voter should give pause, to be fair.

The dumbass in me is thinking if he's scum, the hated town makes sense, and another part of me is thinking if he's town, there's likely to be an executioner somewhere... maybe.

That's the dumbass in me speaking.

 

[RDK]

Leaning town:

Haza - Playing like the town haza I know. Regardless if people think his reads are misguided, he's voting there and double and tripling down. Definitely feels like town Haza to me. I would like to know why he's voting me though.

Ace - Miller claim. no reason to not think that's legit

Those would be the only two I wouldn't lynch outside of sky right now (which is more due to claim than play).

Already told you

 

[Tweet]

Odo being a double voter should give pause, to be fair.

The dumbass in me is thinking if he's scum, the hated town makes sense, and another part of me is thinking if he's town, there's likely to be an executioner somewhere... maybe.

That's the dumbass in me speaking.

This time it's my turn to say "do not like", this post is all setup spec. How about trying to read people on play?

 

[PHEN0M]

Town PHEN0M likes to wallow in his inactivity and relative indifference, whereas Scum PHEN0M likes to make some early posts that look like playing the game but upon further inspection are just window dressing. Sensible window dressing that doesn't actually look scummy in nature but doesn't really mean much or advance the game either. And before you say this isn't true, Magic uses this same tell against you and called you being scum d1 in some recent game on WF, would have to look up which one it was.

This was 100% a scum tell of mine, you don’t think I’d learn? Go take a look at my Day 1 two games ago in OMB’s game.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

I'm voting you because I don't like your defense of someone that I think is scum. OMB has already claimed and told us he is refusing to full claim so i'll see if I can get something out of you instead.

Also goes without saying I trust Odo's intuition

found it! Fair enough on your first point, albeit I think it's misguided and I obviously disagree. I'd be very careful about Odo's intuition after last game though

 

[Shawn]

Phenom voting Tweet because Tweet came after him.

[Looks for Michael Scott "Don't like that" gif, sees it isn't there with the other gifs, wonders why]

Vote Phenom

 

[Canadian Dragon]

vote phenom

 

[PHEN0M]

Phenom voting Tweet because Tweet came after him.

[Looks for Michael Scott "Don't like that" gif, sees it isn't there with the other gifs, wonders why]

Vote Phenom

I voted him because my spider senses go off when i feel like someone is coming up with a read based on nothing. Same reason i voted Sky. Don’t you think it would be disingenuous to vote one based off that and not the other?

For the record, Sky could very well still be scum but I’m not going to be lynching a BG claim day 1.

 

[PHEN0M]

Tweet has since given me a good reason, one which was true before, but I can see him using a read that Magic spelled out in the recent past to throw me off him.

 

[RDK]

Not voting for phenom or his spidey senses

 

[PHEN0M]

I’ll leave my vote there for now and see how things have progressed later.

 

[Tweet]

This was 100% a scum tell of mine, you don’t think I’d learn? Go take a look at my Day 1 two games ago in OMB’s game.

I've seen your last two games as town. As town you enter the thread at your convenience, drop a vote that makes sense on someone with no explanation and sit back. You comment on more or less random things as you see fit. Here, your entrance has been to make two of the most obvious town leans one could give, which is something you probably wouldn't bother doing as town since it's so obvious. As scum you make those kinds of posts to feign looking towny (making reads, making sure to look reasonable) which are things you just don't worry about as town.

That's my take on things, like I said I'm not pushing this to hell and back this time around because last game my attempts to catch scum d1 backfired hard.

And no, I don't think a guy who played this game for over 10 years and self-admittedly puts priority on more important things than Mafia makes a conscious effort to change up his meta.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

I've seen your last two games as town. As town you enter the thread at your convenience, drop a vote that makes sense on someone with no explanation and sit back. You comment on more or less random things as you see fit. Here, your entrance has been to make two of the most obvious town leans one could give, which is something you probably wouldn't bother doing as town since it's so obvious. As scum you make those kinds of posts to feign looking towny (making reads, making sure to look reasonable) which are things you just don't worry about as town.

That's my take on things, like I said I'm not pushing this to hell and back this time around because last game my attempts to catch scum d1 backfired hard.

And no, I don't think a guy who played this game for over 10 years and self-admittedly puts priority on more important things than Mafia makes a conscious effort to change up his meta.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Kind of hard to disagree with that first paragraph by Tweet.