43 vs 86

[The New F'n Show]

Nigel McGuiness

Nigel McGuinness won the ROH title from Takeshi Morishima on October 6th 2007 at Undeniable. He lost the title to Jerry Lynn on April 3rd 2009 at Supercard of Honor.

Mike Awesome

Mike Awesome won the ECW title from Taz in a three way dance also involving Masato Tanaka on September 19th 1999 at Anarchy Rulz. He lost the title to Tanaka on the December 17th 1999 ECW. He won it back on the December 23rd 1999 ECW. He lost the title to Taz on the April 13th 2000 ECW.

 

[Deuce]

I always found Mike Awesome's title reign to be pretty good and I think it was better than Nigel McGuiness's so...... Mike Awesome has my vote.

 

[The New F'n Show]

Really hard here, McGuinness for me, as awesome feud with Tanaka was great but he did little else.

 

[The Wrestling Addict]

Very difficult to decide but I went with McGuiness since his lasted so long.

 

[TheZig]

McGuiness is a easy pick for me.

 

[PHX]

This will be close for sure. I went with Awesome more so cause I actually saw that reign.

 

[Kiffy Lube]

It's Nigel for me, it may be a bit biased but I prefer his reign.

 

[Andrew]

Nigel here. I miss him in the ring

 

[The Hoov]

Mike Awesome will forever leave a bad taste in my mouth and every other ECW fan's mouth so I went with Nigel.

 

[Keith]

Interesting match, but IMO Mcguinness is world class and had one of the best title regins of the recent era, so this was not too hard to call.

 

[The New F'n Show]

Nigel moves on.