Championships and accomplishments
- Future Pro Wrestling
- FPW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Paul Robinson[93]
- Inside The Ropes Magazine
- Ranked No. 10 of the top 50 wrestlers in the world in the ITR 50 in 2020. [94]
- Lucha Britannia
- Lucha Britannia World Championship (2 times)
- Melbourne City Wrestling
- New Japan Pro-Wrestling
- Preston City Wrestling
- PCW 'One to Watch in 2015' End of Year Award (2014)[104]
- Progress Wrestling
- Progress Championship (1 time)
- Progress Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Paul Robinson
- Super Strong Style 16 (2015)
- Thunderbastard (2014) [105]
- Pro Wrestling Australia
- PWA Heavyweight Championship (1 time)[34]
- Pro Wrestling Illustrated
- Reloaded Championship Wrestling Alliance
- RCWA Elite-1 Championship (1 time)[107]
- Revolution Pro Wrestling
- Ring of Honor
- ROH World Television Championship (1 time)[74]
- Best Move of the Year (2017) – OsCutter[111]
- SoCal Uncensored
- Match of the Year (2016) with Matt Sydal and Ricochet vs. Adam Cole and The Young Bucks (Matt Jackson and Nick Jackson) on September 3[112]
- Southside Wrestling Entertainment
- SWE Speed King Championship (2 times)[93]
- What Culture Pro Wrestling/Defiant Wrestling
- WCPW Tag Team Championship (1 time) – with Scotty Wainwright[113]
- Defiant Wrestling Award for Match of the Year (2017) – vs. Drew Galloway on 6 March[114]
- Wrestling Observer Newsletter
- Best Flying Wrestler (2016–2019)[115][116]
- Best Wrestling Maneuver (2019) – Storm Breaker[116]
- Non-Heavyweight MVP (2018, 2019)[117][116]
- Most Outstanding Wrestler (2019) [116]
- Pro Wrestling Match of the Year (2019) vs. Shingo Takagi on June 5 at the Best of the Super Juniors finals[116]
- Other titles
- British Triangle Championship (1 time) – with Paul Robinson and Scott Wainwright[118]
Will Ospreay vs. Ricochet - Semi Final Match (Pro Wrestling World Cup Finals)
Will Ospreay Vs Matt Riddle from #ScrapperMania4
Dragon Lee vs Will Ospreay: FULL MATCH! (ROH Manhattan Mayhem 2017)
Will Ospreay vs. KUSHIDA - Pro Wrestling World Cup Final
Pete Dunne vs Will Ospreay (TNT Extreme)
Walter vs Will Ospreay, First-Time Ever! (Internet Championship, Stacked '18)