The 4th Annual WrestlingSharts Awards - Final Voting Phase!

[Sky]

The nominations are in, and the results will now be decided! It's time to determine the worst of wrestling in 2023!

Rules
Each voter will DM me with the name of the one nominee they want to win each award.
You do not have to vote in each category, but it is extremely encouraged.
VOTING ENDS MIDNIGHT GMT, FEBRUARY 2/3

Categories
Here they are! All nominees are presented in alphabetical order, except matches, which are in chronological order.

Worst in the Ring: Male
Gable Steveson
nZo
Omos
Tommy Dreamer
Tyrus
Vampiro

Worst in the Ring: Female
Nia Jax
Ronda Rousey
Roxanne Perez
Saraya
Shotzi

Worst on the Mic: Male
Baron Corbin
Jack Perry
Lexis King
Shinsuke Nakamura
Tyrus

Worst on the Mic: Female
Cora Jade
IYO SKY
Ronda Rousey
Saraya
Shotzi

The Alliance as Bad as the WCW/ECW One Award
Blunt Force Trauma
Idolmania Sports Management
QTV
Schism
The Brothers of Funstruction
The Outcasts

The Randy Rosenbloom Award for Worst Commentator
Booker T
Jim Ross
Michael Cole
Thom Fain
Velvet Sky

The Mike Shaw Memorial Award for Worst Gimmick
David Finlay (We have Jay White at home)
Dirty Dango (Jaded meta guy who cuts boring promos every week)
Jake Hager (Likes this hat)
Lexis King (Claims to hate his father, is a clone of his father)
MAGA Butcher (Necro becomes a proud boy)
SCRYPTS (Reggie still in a rubbish mask)
Tyrus (Fox News crossover champion and "wrestling machine")

The Test/Wight Award for Worst Finisher
A-Town Down (Austin Theory)
BFT (LA Knight)
Heart Punch and/or Tongan Death Grip (Tyrus)
ObLIVion (Liv Morgan)
Stunner with Unnecessary Roll (Grayson Waller)

Most Overpushed
EC3
Jon Moxley
Saraya
Seth "Freakin" Rollins
Tommy Dreamer
Tyrus

Worst Burial
Cameron Grimes called up just to job
Jay White literally fails to beat a one-legged man in an ass-kicking contest
LA Knight around WM39, getting his pop EDITED OUT because reasons
Mustafa Ali (self-explanatory)
Starlight Kid has a horrible 5 Star GP

The "Minus Five Stars" Worst Match Award
Big F'N Joe vs. The Body (the one with the syringe in the penis) (2023-03-25 XPW Here Comes Revenge)
Vampiro/Jack Evans/Aramis vs. Pagano/Bestia 666/Mecha Wolf 450 (2023-07-15 AAA TripleMania XXXI Tijuana)
Baron Corbin vs. Gable Steveson (2023-07-30 NXT The Great American Bash)
Ronda Rousey vs. Shayna Baszler, MMA Rules (2023-08-05 WWE SummerSlam)
Tyrus vs. EC3, Bullrope Match (2023-08-27 NWA 75)

Worst Non-Wrestling Segment of the Year
Jimmy Uso explains why he screwed Jey (and makes no sense)
Leatherface arrives in AEW
The American Nightmare Before Christmas
The first ever Busted Open Live... on an Impact PPV
Tyrus' retirement speech at NWA 75

The Worst Feud Award, sponsored by Glenn Jacobs for Knox County Mayor
Ronda Rousey vs. Shayna Baszler
Roxanne Perez vs. Kiana James
SCRYPTS vs. Axiom
The Outcasts vs. AEW Originals
Tommy Dreamer vs. Bully Ray

Worst TV Show of the Year
Dynamite (AEW)
OVW TV (OVW)
Powerrr (NWA)
Rampage (AEW)
RAW (WWE)

Worst Major Show of the Year
312 (NWA)
NWA 75th Anniversary (NWA)
Samhain (NWA)
TripleMania XXXI, collectively (AAA)
WrestleMania 39 Night 2 (WWE)

The Award for Worst Company of the Year
Lucha Libre AAA Worldwide
National Wrestling Alliance
Xtreme Pro Wrestling

The "Wrestling Promoters Are Garbage" Moment of the Year
AAA roster supports Cuatrero / indie show held in front of the jail where he's held for trying to kill Vaquer
Tony Khan bashes Vince for sexual misconduct, then brings in Ric Flair
Tony Khan continues to cater to CM Punk despite backstage issues
WWE pushing rapist Gable Steveson
XPW syringe penis spot

Hearbreaking Injury of the Year
Bryan Danielson
Dante Martin
Jamie Hayter
Mickie James
Utami Hayashishita
Wes Lee

VOTING ENDS MIDNIGHT GMT, FEBRUARY 2/3​

 

[Vegeta]

Who the fuck nominated Jake Hager and his hat as worst gimmick?? I just wanna talk.

 

[Kenoh]

Whoever nominated Shinsuke, Iyo, and David Finlay, I just want to say one thing. We ain't friends.

 

[Storm Trooper]

Shinsuke has literally been one of the best promos the past like 5 months or whatever. Once they let him speak his native language his shits been outstanding.

 

[Vegeta]

Shinsuke has literally been one of the best promos the past like 5 months or whatever. Once they let him speak his native language his shits been outstanding.

I blame Sabs

 

[BSE]

Michael Cole is one of the best commentators in wrestling

 

[Storm Trooper]

Michael Cole is one of the best commentators in wrestling

honestly not even one of. Just the best. the hate he gets is crazy. Yeah he wasn't very good back in the Attitude Era. No shit he was greener than goose shit. But he's been far and away the best for many years now.

 

[Chris]

The only one I really take issue with with is Corbin for worst on mic, dude was so good this year IMO

 

[Vegeta]

honestly not even one of. Just the best. the hate he gets is crazy. Yeah he wasn't very good back in the Attitude Era. No shit he was greener than goose shit. But he's been far and away the best for many years now.

Uh idk if I say many years. Like he was pretty annoying well into the 2010s. I say around when Pat came in is when he got to be good

 

[Kenoh]

The only one I really take issue with with is Corbin for worst on mic, dude was so good this year IMO

His promo against Ilja was so good

 

[Gentleman Jake]

The only one I really take issue with with is Corbin for worst on mic, dude was so good this year IMO

I’m not even a fan but worst in ring for Roxanne Perez is a weird one

 

[Vegeta]

But he was also good on stuff that Vince wasn’t doing much with like that UK Tournament. So I’ll give him that

 

[Rosie]

Vote SLK's Terrible Five Star for Worst Burial, it broke my heart.

 

[Storm Trooper]

Uh idk if I say many years. Like he was pretty annoying well into the 2010s. I say around when Pat came in is when he got to be good

that's when he really became nearly universally loved.

Even in the 2010's he was doing his job and doing a damn good job of it. You may not have liked the style that he was doing but he was doing what he was asked to do and doing it well. And I'll be honest in hindsight I kinda liked Heel Cole. It lasted way too long and it should have ended at Mania.

 

[Rosie]

Whoever nominated Shinsuke, Iyo, and David Finlay, I just want to say one thing. We ain't friends.

"Hey let's vote the Japanese people for terrible mic work even though they're speaking in their second language when speaking English and the other is speaking badass Japanese promos now"

David Finlay, sorry, dude's been lacking in comparison to other BC leaders. All either had an "It Factor" or something. He's still finding it and even if Jay had to develop into the role, he had progress. David's not developed as quickly. At least he seems to have debuted a new finisher.