Round 1: Quadrant 7 Matchup 3

[The New F'n Show]

3. Umaga

14. Jim Neidhart

 

[BDC]

Sorry Jim....I gotta go with Umaga out of pure presence and impact in the ring! And outta respect!

 

[Kiffy Lube]

Umaga actually got taken seriously in the main event scene. Jim only got glimpses at the top thanks to his association with the Hart Family.

 

[PHX]

Umaga should have got a chance to be champ tbh and was way more believable than Jim could ever be.

 

[AZUCAR!]

Umaga

 

[Keith]

Neidhart had a good personaity, but was always a tag wrestler, Umaga turned out to be a soild big guy who could have been a credible world champion.

 

[Chris]

I don't think I ever saw a singles match of Neidhart's that I liked. He just wasn't very good in the ring, though he had a cool look. Umaga was a great monster heel, and I'm surprised he never got the belt. Khali did after all.

 

[Canadian Pothead]

Umaga for sure, Jim Neidhart was nothing more than a tag team partner in my eyes.

 

[The New F'n Show]

With everyone else here, no need to explain.

 

[Heisenberg]

Umaga. Got great heat and had a great character. Basically all the reasons stated above.

 

[The Cork]

Umaga vs Cena, Royal Rumble 2007 > Anything Jim Neidhart related

 

[Smartmark]

Umaga gets my vote. One of WWE's succesfull monster heels

 

[chefboyardee]

umanga.if they woulda ever let him talk i think he woulda eventually got the gold because he was a big time talent.

 

[Troy]

Umaga gets my vote. That gimmick change worked brilliantly for him and he performed it to perfection with AAE at his side. He should have gotten at least a short transitional reign during that epic feud with Cena.

 

[Tapout]

Wow. I'm really glad everyone saw the greatness in Umaga. I thought this would be different, and Neidhart would win on name alone.

R.I.P Umaga