PPV2: Andy vs. Prodigy

[Andy]

Andy's Entry

Prodigy's Entry

When voting, please clearly specify who you are voting for. Support for your vote is greatly appreciated but not required.
The battle will close on Tuesday June 5, 2012 at 10 P.M. (Central Time)
Good luck!​

 

[Andrew]

Prodigy gets my vote

 

[Doink]

Andy gets my vote, I really like that piece.

 

[Prodigy]

Guys I appreciate you voting, for or against me, but please, instead of simple posts I'd appreciate some feedback. These simple ______ gets my vote posts do nothing to help people improve.

 

[Doink]

Guys I appreciate you voting, for or against me, but please, instead of simple posts I'd appreciate some feedback. These simple ______ gets my vote posts do nothing to help people improve.

I don't really know what to say since you made it in 2009. I think you've improved a mile and this was a weaker piece.

 

[!PHENOM!]

Andy:i like it simple but effective...more like the texts and BG...a weak point may a the border and Black,white color chosen...but overall a creative peice....
Prodigy: big time fan of lighting bolts effects...and undertaker render blending....weak point may be the texts here only.....i think this was your past work that's why the texts not that good much....but really a good competition....

Prodigy gets my vote...i like the overall execution of prodigy with more points

 

[Rated R Superstar]

Andy gets my vote, it just looks cleaner and smooth. And it has a really classic feel to it, in a modern way. If that makes sense.

Prodigy, yours is good, but it just doesn't jump out at me. I personally think that Taker should be highlighted just a little more.

 

[Defiant]

Voting for Andy. Everything flows and its just easy to look at. The text needs some work though, you can't read it on first glance.

Prodigy, the overall atmosphere is fine but I think the Punk render needs to be brought out a bit more and the branding centered.

 

[The_King]

Andy: I know you said that you just threw this together, but I really like it. Everything flows well. It's very appealing and has a unique look to it. Text isn't the best though.
Prodigy: This one just isn't one of my favorites of yours. It seems like a very foggy atmosphere, but there's a random lightning bolt coming from the side that doesn't really fit. The Undertaker face in the background looks a bit awkward since the Punk blocks his mouth entirely. I think the colors needed to be more distinct because the gray/light purple leaves the piece lacking. Sorry if all that was harsh!

My vote goes to Andy.

 

[Prodigy]

Damn, shudda used one of my newer pieces s

 

[Doink]

Damn, shudda used one of my newer pieces s

I think that would have worked out better, you are a great artist but I think it was a wrong selection this time.

 

[Andy]

The battle is now closed.
Andy (4) def. Prodigy (2)