LC15: Alpha Dog Battle- !PHENOM! (c) v. BDC

[The_King]

!PHENOM!'s (c) Entry

BDC's Entry

When voting, please clearly specify who you are voting for. Support for your vote is greatly appreciated but not required.
The battle will close on Saturday, August 25, 2012 at 11:59 P.M. (Central Time)Good luck!​

 

[Pete]

This is a very hard vote. BDC's piece is perhaps the best I've seen from him, and as a stand alone it works. But next to Phenom's...I don't know. I LOVE the water effect on Phenom's, but I think the lettering ruins the effect somewhat, and sticks out in a negative way. I would especially have done without the letters at the top.

But I still have to vote for Phenom. Sorry Beedz

 

[Doink]

Going for BDC here in a very close one, well done BDC you really stepped it up this week. In the end though BDC takes it because I don't really like that effect on the water. Both great pieces

 

[Defiant]

Your getting better at this, BDC. But I still gotta go with Phenom. It feels more like a moment captured than a collage of action shots.

 

[The_King]

Phenom: Very cool looking. Water effect really works. Main render flows well with the rest of the piece. Font for the sub-text is okay, but the main font is great.
BDC: Definitely one of your better pieces. Blending is great, but it could use some effects, just a bit plain.

My vote goes to Phenom.

Could we get some more votes in this battle and the other one?

 

[Chris]

Close, but I went with PHENOM even though I really, really dislike the text. I love the water and the American flag used. BDC's piece is very good as well, one of the best I've seen from him, but PHENOM slightly edges it out.

 

[Tapout]

BDC for me.

Phenom always does good work, but this is a huge step up for BDC. He gets my vote for his amazing amount of improvement

 

[The_King]

The battle is now closed.
!PHENOM! (4) def. BDC (2).
Congrats on the win!

 

[BDC]

Thanks guys. I loved the way mine turned out. very pleased. Just not in Phenom's league yet. Very encouraging.