Best Holiday Film Round 1b: Home Alone 2: Lost in New York (10) vs Miracle on 34th Street (23)

[Chris]

Home Alone 2: Lost in New York
Release Date: November 20, 1992
Directed by: Chris Columbus
Starring: Macaulay Culkin, Joe Pesci, Daniel Stern, John Heard, Tim Curry, Brenda Fricker, Catherine O'Hara
Plot: One year after Kevin McCallister was left home alone and had to defeat a pair of bumbling burglars, he accidentally finds himself stranded in New York City - and the same criminals are not far behind.



VS

A Miracle on 34th Street
Release Date: June 11, 1947
Directed by: George Seaton
Starring: Maureen O'Hara, John Payne, Edmund Gwenn, Gene Lockhart, Natalie Wood, Porter Hall, William Frawley, Jerome Cowan, Philip Tonge
Plot: After a divorced New York mother hires a nice old man to play Santa Claus at Macy's, she is startled by his claim to be the genuine article. When his sanity is questioned, a lawyer defends him in court by arguing that he's not mistaken.
​

 

[Marty McFourth]

So tough

I am leaning towards Home Alone 2, the traps are hilarious in that one. He legit electrocutes them and shit, it's wild.

 

[Chris]

Easily Miracle for me. I used to actually like Home Alone 2 better than the first but it was mostly cause I had it on VHS as a kid first seemed boring to me bc it was in one house most of the time...and now that's what I like better. And miracle is one of my top films like ever, not even Christmas so no contest

 

[Hook]

Home alone 2 even though it’s a copy of 1

 

[Keith]

Its Miracle for me. If it was up against the first Home Alone it would be more of a fight.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

I'm a simple 90s guy and I vote that way