How're they doomed to fail? Cause they'll break up? All stables break up.
From the beginning, Evolution was about getting Randy and Dave over by using Triple H and Flair.
Karl and Gallows can use AJ to get over then Finn can use them. Circle of life
Did you read his response? He made it clear that the reason they'll break up is because Finn Balor named it after himself. So it was doomed the moment he named it Balor Club.
Evolution get everyone over. Randy Orton developed his Legend Killer gimmick, Batista became a top guy during this period and Triple H reinvented himself and strangled the main event for years.
Obviously, Anderson and Gallows will mostly get the leader over, but they don't want to be called "Balor Club" and only do that. That t-shirt is for what he calls his fans. Like the Cesaro Section. He wouldn't form a faction and name it that.
Of course, all factions break up, but you have to use suspension of disbelief that they won't. The Bullet Club has been around for 3 years and just added Adam Cole on the latest ROH event. Balor Club doesn't have that kind of lifespan.