Is Kelly really a prime example? They plucked her fresh from high school and threw her on tv over developmental. She essentially stuck around as long as anyone could expect for someone so young. She's wwe youngest female signing ever. They got 6 years, constant travel, and made money off her stripping and put her face all over the division ... She's even young and healthy enough to return if she ever chose to
I mean there is no guarantee Indy girls will stick with it. Case and point the last 2 Indy girls have fucked the, over in a much shorter time than any of the diva search contestants have. There was Kong who took a years worth of free checks and basically used their cash to fund her pregnancy and extended vacation. There was the last girl, who they signed months ago from the indies who entered rehab on their dime shortly after and asked to be related. Even Vickie and Eddies daughter took their pay and training, and said I'm out after they featured her in few and NXT because PF family name.
Say what you want about Mccool but she gave them years, injuries, worked constant matches and the like. She just left to be a mother after aging, but they miled the hell out of LayCool. Melina gave them years. The Bella's were their top ambassadors for years, and they fulfilled the most wishes of any divas which is good PR. Layla has given them years and was successful, she just missed a bunch of time after getting hurt.
at the end of the day, we know why they go the model/fitness route over Indy girls ... Trish ... She was the standard of diva, what they want to replicate, and made the division more important than any woman wrestler ever did before or after her, and they want another diva who has that look, that personality, that youth, and that willingness to improve which they feel the I dy crop lacks. And strangely enough, short of Rosita there is no one who can really fit that bill