ok, the concept of it is good. but let me give you some hints here.
1- the left side looked better than the right side and thats because of the cutting effeciency. Try to cut more for batista psd and the murdock psd. Also enhance the image and dont lower its opacity too much, compared to the other psds.
2-As its a poster, you could have used the WWE logo there, it would add more meaning to it.
3-You may not use both kind of fonts together. That distorted font with the basic simple font. Either you place that distorted font some where away from the simple font (with lowering the opacity of this distorted font) or just change this font to something else. This is coz it will lower the standard of your poster.
4-You can darken the blue color abit. This is by adding some shadow to it, or add something like 12-20% opacity black/white gradient to the whole thing at the end.
Keep the good work dude.