i like it, but let me give feedback on the second version..
-the psd has way too much darkness to its right side (face of kennedy).
-text stands more than it should. plus the MR. should not be overlaping the mic like that imo.
-the vector behind the mic is a good idea.
-scanlines are ok, but you could have made half of the bkg scanlined rather than all the bkg, just for a change and from that you can add something else.. (hence a spots scans rather than lines on the other half).
-the scratching lines on the psd werent neccessary imo. If you really wanted to add those, you could have added atleast fainted ones to the bkg and apply some to the mic as well, and make the ones on him are co-related with the ones coming from mic but with less opacity.