I wouldn't really expect a chick to enjoy Gangs of New York anyway.
let me guess, you are one of those hipsters who had Shutter Island 'all figured out' just from a 3 second clip of the trailer, right
ity2:
I never said they were bad movies, but you can't deny they're at the bottom of the Scorsese pile. Do you honestly think Shutter Island is in the same class as Taxi Driver or Raging Bull?
Let me put it this way: rank all of Scorsese's films and tell me if Shutter Island isn't near the bottom. And since you mentioned it, I did have most of the movie "figured out" pretty early, but it's not because I'm a hipster, it's because I'm aware of of the cliches and narrative devices commonly employed in movies of that genre. Lack of originality = not so great movie. It was entertaining and all, but that's it.
Gangs of New York was good, I'm not saying it wasn't, but frankly it wasn't up to Scorsese's standard. As a "chick" I can admit that much of the macho sentimentality was wasted on me, but sentimentality in all it's forms is poor storytelling. The movie suffered from taking itself too seriously. It sacrificed substance for style.
All of Scorsese's movies are brilliant in a fanboy sense, but some are better than others. That's all I was saying. Scorsese's one of my all time favorite filmmakers, so I tend to be a little picky.