Taped on January 11th, 2012. Airs on January 13th, 2012.
Dark Matches:
- Paredyse defeated Heath Hatton by pinfall following the Erectile Dysfunction.
- "Sexy" Sean Casey and Raphael Constantine (with the Sexettes) defeated Jimbo Onoo and Elvis Pridemoore by pinfall with a double-leg sweep.
- Brandon Espinosa defeated Andrew Patton by pinfall following the CombOver. After the match, he put a dress and make-up on Patton.
TV Taping:
- The Mascagni Family (Rudy Switchblade, Marcus Anthony, "Mr. Pec-Tacular" Jesse Godderz, led by Christian Mascagni) and Mohamad Ali Vaez came out to the ring. Christian praised his team, then welcomed Ali to the family. The group began praising each other and talking down to the other wrestlers when OMG ("Smooth" Johnny Spade and Shiloh Jonze) and Jason Wayne came out to the ring to belittle the group for their actions against Michael Hayes at the SNS. The Mascagni Family reacted, challenging OMG to a tag team championship match. OMG agreed.
- The Mascagni Family (Jesse Godderz and Marcus Anthony) defeated OVW Tag Team Champions OMG ("Smooth" Johnny Spade and Shiloh Jonze) by pinfall to win the OVW Tag Team Championships.
- Backstage, James "Moose" Thomas and Christopher Bolin were looking for a tag team partner for the evening's tag team match. They approached Joe Coleman to be his tag partner. Coleman agreed. Somewhere in there, Bolin grabbed Mickey McMichaels and told Mickey that he'd be Bolin's assistant from now on.
- A promotional video was shown with Team TieDye (Christopher Silvio, Mo Green, and Taryn Shay). They spoke about how Team TieDye is the best, and they had the TV title to prove it.
- OVW Television Champion Christopher Silvio (w/ Mo Green) defeated Randy Terrez by pinfall following the RocketPunch.
- Anarquia and Raul "Rudo" LaMotta defeated Joe Coleman and James "Moose" Thomas (w/ Christopher Bolin and Mickey McMichael) by pinfall after a hangman's neckbreaker. After the match, Bolin tried to run but was stopped by the returning Jack Black. Bolin was taken into the ring and his shirt was raised to receive the 15 lashes, and when Jack Black went to dish them out, he then attacked Rudo and Anarquia, joining Bolin Services 2.0.
- OVW's Papa John's Replay showed Trailer Park Trash making a battle royal to determine the number one contender for the OVW title, then Ted McNaler winning.
- OVW Heavyweight Champion Rudy Switchblade defeated Ted McNaler by pinfall. The Mascagni Family tried to interfere at one point but were cut off at the pass by OMG and Jason Wayne. However, Adam Revolver made his way out and attacked Ted from behind, allowing Rudy to get the Evenflow DDT on Ted for the pin.
- The OVW roster came out to the ringside area. Michael Hayes came out to a huge ovation. He spoke to the fans about how he's a man of his word, and he keeps his promises. He thanked everyone for believing in him, including the fans and his peers. The Mascagni Family was shown on the screen laughing at Hayes. Danny Davis came out to say a few kind words about Hayes, calling him "the greatest man he's ever known". The OVW audience cheered in agreement. Davis then made 2 matches for next week's tapings: OMG Vs. Marcus and Godderz for the OVW Tag Team Championships, and Jason Wayne Vs. Rudy Switchblade for the OVW Heavyweight Championship. In both matches, if the rest of the Mascagni Family interfered, they'd all be fired. He then shook Hayes' hand to end the show.
Dark Matches:
- Jason Wayne defeated "Marksman" Nick Dumeyer by submission.
- Mike Mondo defeated Tony Gunn by pinfall following the Gut Check.
Biggest Pops:
- Michael Hayes
- Christopher Bolin about to be lashed.
- OMG and Jason Wayne
Biggest Heat:
- The Mascagni Family
- Jack Black joining Bolin Services 2.0
- Brandon Espinosa
PWI
Dark Matches:
- Paredyse defeated Heath Hatton by pinfall following the Erectile Dysfunction.
- "Sexy" Sean Casey and Raphael Constantine (with the Sexettes) defeated Jimbo Onoo and Elvis Pridemoore by pinfall with a double-leg sweep.
- Brandon Espinosa defeated Andrew Patton by pinfall following the CombOver. After the match, he put a dress and make-up on Patton.
TV Taping:
- The Mascagni Family (Rudy Switchblade, Marcus Anthony, "Mr. Pec-Tacular" Jesse Godderz, led by Christian Mascagni) and Mohamad Ali Vaez came out to the ring. Christian praised his team, then welcomed Ali to the family. The group began praising each other and talking down to the other wrestlers when OMG ("Smooth" Johnny Spade and Shiloh Jonze) and Jason Wayne came out to the ring to belittle the group for their actions against Michael Hayes at the SNS. The Mascagni Family reacted, challenging OMG to a tag team championship match. OMG agreed.
- The Mascagni Family (Jesse Godderz and Marcus Anthony) defeated OVW Tag Team Champions OMG ("Smooth" Johnny Spade and Shiloh Jonze) by pinfall to win the OVW Tag Team Championships.
- Backstage, James "Moose" Thomas and Christopher Bolin were looking for a tag team partner for the evening's tag team match. They approached Joe Coleman to be his tag partner. Coleman agreed. Somewhere in there, Bolin grabbed Mickey McMichaels and told Mickey that he'd be Bolin's assistant from now on.
- A promotional video was shown with Team TieDye (Christopher Silvio, Mo Green, and Taryn Shay). They spoke about how Team TieDye is the best, and they had the TV title to prove it.
- OVW Television Champion Christopher Silvio (w/ Mo Green) defeated Randy Terrez by pinfall following the RocketPunch.
- Anarquia and Raul "Rudo" LaMotta defeated Joe Coleman and James "Moose" Thomas (w/ Christopher Bolin and Mickey McMichael) by pinfall after a hangman's neckbreaker. After the match, Bolin tried to run but was stopped by the returning Jack Black. Bolin was taken into the ring and his shirt was raised to receive the 15 lashes, and when Jack Black went to dish them out, he then attacked Rudo and Anarquia, joining Bolin Services 2.0.
- OVW's Papa John's Replay showed Trailer Park Trash making a battle royal to determine the number one contender for the OVW title, then Ted McNaler winning.
- OVW Heavyweight Champion Rudy Switchblade defeated Ted McNaler by pinfall. The Mascagni Family tried to interfere at one point but were cut off at the pass by OMG and Jason Wayne. However, Adam Revolver made his way out and attacked Ted from behind, allowing Rudy to get the Evenflow DDT on Ted for the pin.
- The OVW roster came out to the ringside area. Michael Hayes came out to a huge ovation. He spoke to the fans about how he's a man of his word, and he keeps his promises. He thanked everyone for believing in him, including the fans and his peers. The Mascagni Family was shown on the screen laughing at Hayes. Danny Davis came out to say a few kind words about Hayes, calling him "the greatest man he's ever known". The OVW audience cheered in agreement. Davis then made 2 matches for next week's tapings: OMG Vs. Marcus and Godderz for the OVW Tag Team Championships, and Jason Wayne Vs. Rudy Switchblade for the OVW Heavyweight Championship. In both matches, if the rest of the Mascagni Family interfered, they'd all be fired. He then shook Hayes' hand to end the show.
Dark Matches:
- Jason Wayne defeated "Marksman" Nick Dumeyer by submission.
- Mike Mondo defeated Tony Gunn by pinfall following the Gut Check.
Biggest Pops:
- Michael Hayes
- Christopher Bolin about to be lashed.
- OMG and Jason Wayne
Biggest Heat:
- The Mascagni Family
- Jack Black joining Bolin Services 2.0
- Brandon Espinosa
PWI