The 5th Annual WrestlingSharts Awards - Final Voting Phase!

  • Welcome to "The New" Wrestling Smarks Forum!

    I see that you are not currently registered on our forum. It only takes a second, and you can even login with your Facebook! If you would like to register now, pease click here: Register

    Once registered please introduce yourself in our introduction thread which can be found here: Introduction Board


Leon TrotSky

TOTAL NONSTOP ACTION
Joined
Apr 17, 2019
Messages
83,319
Reaction score
24,443
Points
113
Location
The Impact Zone, Scotland
Favorite Wrestler
velvetsky
The nominations are in, and the results will now be decided! It's time to determine the worst of wrestling in 2024!

Rules
Each voter will DM me with the name of the one nominee they want to win each award.
You do not have to vote in each category, but it is extremely encouraged.
VOTING ENDS MIDNIGHT GMT, FEBRUARY 2/3

Categories

Here they are! All nominees are presented in alphabetical order, except matches, which are in chronological order.

Worst in the Ring: Male
Alberto El Patron
Jinder Mahal
Ridge Holland
Solo Sikoa
Tonga Loa
Vampiro

Worst in the Ring: Female
Dr. Britt Baker D.M.D.
Jade Cargill
Kamille
Maxxine Dupri
Nia Jax
Saraya

Worst on the Mic: Male
Andrade
Chris Jericho
EC3
Kyle O'Reilly
Solo Sikoa
Vampiro

Worst on the Mic: Female
ASH by Elegance
Kamille
Kelani Jordan
Nia Jax
Saraya
Zoey Stark

The Alliance as Bad as the WCW/ECW One Award
AAA's Eye group
Pure Fusion Collective
Solo Sikoa's Bloodline
The Learning Tree (AEW, not TNA)
The Pride
The System

The Randy Rosenbloom Award for Worst Commentator
Booker T
Corey Graves
Jim Ross
Joe Galli
Larry Dallas

The Mike Shaw Memorial Award for Worst Gimmick
ASH by Elegance (I'm guessing... a perfume bottle?)
Chris Jericho (The Learning Tree / Jericho ego stroke no. 500 million)
Jonathan Gresham (Unexplained, disappearing ink mask)
MJF (American Hero and American Champion)
Wendy Choo (Sleep paralysis demon)

The Test/Wight Award for Worst Finisher
Hipnotic (Jaida Parker)
Mone Maker (Mercedes Mone)
ObLIVion (Liv Morgan)
One Lucky Punch (Logan Paul)
The Final Prayer (Karrion Kross)

Most Overpushed
Chris Jericho
Logan Paul
Roxanne Perez
Solo Sikoa
Vampiro

Worst Burial
Chad Gable and American Made are a totally useless faction
Cody Rhodes self-buries by giving his shot to the Rock
Every domestic babyface in AAA, especially those under 40
Giovanni Vinci appears on SmackDown, loses, never comes back
Ricky Starks disappears from AEW TV
Serena Deeb: "Nobody cares" -Britt Baker

The "Minus Five Stars" Worst Match Award
Kota Ibushi vs. Naomichi Marufuji - NOAH The New Year
Von Wagner vs. Lexis King - WWE NXT 2024-04-02
Jey Uso vs. Jimmy Uso - WWE WrestleMania XL
Team Vampiro vs. La Secta - AAA TripleMania XXXII Monterrey
Mercedes Mone vs. Dr. Britt Baker D.M.D. - AEW All In
Chris Jericho vs. Mistico - CMLL 91. Aniversario

Worst Non-Wrestling Segment of the Year
AAA's Eye group reveals itself after Alberto turns heel
Cody Rhodes hands his WrestleMania shot to the Rock
Tessa Blanchard returns and attacks Jordynnne Grace
The Elite shows the All In footage
TV Time with Chris Jericho (in general)

The Worst Feud Award, sponsored by Glenn Jacobs for Knox County Mayor
Adam Cole vs. MJF
Chris Jericho vs. HOOK
Konnan vs. Latin Lover
Rhea Ripley/Damian Priest vs. Liv Morgan/Judgement Day
The Final Testament vs. The Pride

Worst TV Show of the Year
AAA TV (AAA)
Collision (AEW)
Impact (TNA)
Powerrr (NWA)
Rampage (AEW)
SmackDown (WWE)

Worst Major Show of the Year
AAA TripleMania XXXII, collectively
AEW Full Gear
MLW Eric Bischoff's OneShot
WWE Bad Blood
WWE Crown Jewel

The :cornette Award for Worst Company of the Year
Game Changer Wrestling
Lucha Libre AAA Worldwide
Major League Wrestling
National Wrestling Alliance
Total Nonstop Action Wrestling

The "Wrestling Promoters Are Garbage" Moment of the Year
Beyond brings back Drew Gulak to shoot on his sexual harassment case
DDT's Danshoku Dino doing his sex offender act vs. a 16 year old
Journey Fatu's missing person angle
NXT's Brooks Jensen release angle, including his girlfriend teasing a worked shoot suicide
TNA fires Scott D'Amore
WWE pushing Logan Paul / Prime
WWE's treatment of the Janel Grant lawsuit (HHH ducking hard questions / Liv/Dom angle parallels with lawsuit info)

Dumbest Podcaster of the Year
Bully Ray
Disco Inferno
Eric Bischoff
Logan Paul
Mark Henry
The Undertaker

VOTING ENDS MIDNIGHT GMT, FEBRUARY 2/3
 

Comrade Khan

The Ace of WS
Joined
Dec 2, 2019
Messages
249,225
Reaction score
78,189
Points
118
Age
38
Favorite Wrestler
9yQJpez
Favorite Wrestler
9Cf16sP
Absolutely great and fair list. No notes.
 

Comrade Khan

The Ace of WS
Joined
Dec 2, 2019
Messages
249,225
Reaction score
78,189
Points
118
Age
38
Favorite Wrestler
9yQJpez
Favorite Wrestler
9Cf16sP
Jericho is this years nwa/cyn in pure noms. You deserve it! Clap clap clap clap clap!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leon TrotSky

Tyler2

Abap
Joined
Dec 21, 2017
Messages
1,726
Reaction score
835
Points
113
Location
Raisin Canes
Favorite Wrestler
ajstyles
Favorite Wrestler
Hv5zY64
Favorite Wrestler
shawnmichaels
Favorite Wrestler
reymysterio
Favorite Wrestler
rvd
Favorite Wrestler
randyorton
Favorite Sports Team
rRE8Tx2
Favorite Sports Team
dJHMFjb
Worst in the Ring: Male

Ridge Holland sorry Shawn but this guy ain't main event material


Worst in the Ring: Female

Nia Jax improved but almost murdered Lyra

Worst on the Mic: Male

EC3 dummy yeah


Worst on the Mic: Female

Zoey Stark

The Alliance as Bad as the WCW/ECW One Award

Pure Fusion Collective


The Randy Rosenbloom Award for Worst Commentator

Corey Graves is Carmella close with Triple Why is this midlife crisis emo still on commentary?


The Mike Shaw Memorial Award for Worst Gimmick

Chris Jericho (The Learning Tree / Jericho ego stroke no. 500 million)


The Test/Wight Award for Worst Finisher

One Lucky Punch (Logan Paul)


Most Overpushed

Logan Paul fuck this guy


Worst Burial

Giovanni Vinci appears on SmackDown, loses, never comes back


The "Minus Five Stars" Worst Match Award

Jey Uso vs. Jimmy Uso - WWE WrestleMania XL


Worst Non-Wrestling Segment of the Year

Tessa Blanchard returns and attacks Jordynnne Grace
It's the nega chin

The Worst Feud Award, sponsored by Glenn Jacobs for Knox County Mayor
Rhea Ripley/Damian Priest vs. Liv Morgan/Judgement Day


Worst TV Show of the Year

Rampage (AEW)


Worst Major Show of the Year

MLW Eric Bischoff's OneShot

The :cornette Award for Worst Company of the Year
Game

National Wrestling Alliance


The "Wrestling Promoters Are Garbage" Moment of the Year

WWE's treatment of the Janel Grant lawsuit (HHH ducking hard questions / Liv/Dom angle parallels with lawsuit info)

Dumbest Podcaster of the Year
The Undertaker imagine endorsing a racist and then acting shocked that fans call you a nazi