StaticX vs Natedog.GFX

[StaticX]

StaticX's Entry

Natedog.GFX's Entry

Please vote for the best!

 

[Solid Stinger the Big Boss]

StaticX gets my vote


Nate's is too pixelated for me to see clearly and I don't like the color and effects you used.

 

[gamebreaker]

static wins and owns natedog's sig
it doesnt even look like chris jericho in nate's sig
and like stinger said, it looks wayyy too pixelated

 

[JC Punk]

Had to go with my buddy StaticX very nice sig. I like the pen tool effect. You used it very nicely.

 

[exC.On]

static X just like it better nothing majorly wrong with the other one

just a tip static X ive seen that swirly wire on some of your works..just dont get it to be a habit cause it wont be as good if you keep using it.

 

[Enigma22]

natedogg ur only big problem is that the scan lines are to opac. lower the opacity and it would look better. static u got my vote... although i think ur sig has to much of a soft look... idk how to explain that more lol...

 

[AnkleBreaker]

Static. His text is readable, great effects.
nate. the effects messed the sig up big time.

Static gets my vote

 

[Enigma22]

i wanna add that honestly id rather use natedogs sig in my sig if i was choosing between the 2 but statics is graphically better.

 

[StaticX]

Thanks guys.. one more thing.. according to the rules, voting ends 3 days after the voting starts right?

 

[Enigma22]

ya you are supposed to make the poll close after three days

 

[C4]

Background, text, effects and everything else done perfectly and of course better than the other one and therefore:

StaticX gets my vote!

 

[StaticX]

StaticX : 10
Natedog.GFX : 1

 

[The Outkast Kid]

Well im saying Natedog. The scan lines arent that bad, the pic is a shiny one blended in maybe too much and distorts his face. its nowhere near pixelated...tbh...the text is readable.

The outer glow on bret hart and the speed txt look or whatever..not doing it...your electrical swirl...come on...in every sig? you dont even have an electrical theme, you gotta use it when you need it, not just in every sig, sure its good to have a trademark but damn...have the time it dont even look right.

but if you wanted my honest opinion I wouldnt use either of them in a sig. they both need a lot of work to really flow as when you look at it there are a lot of speed bumps in both sigs.

I am not saying im the master at sig making but..this is just my opinion and thats all your asking right? there you have it