So, Who's On The Mt. Rushmore Of WCW And ECW?

  • Welcome to "The New" Wrestling Smarks Forum!

    I see that you are not currently registered on our forum. It only takes a second, and you can even login with your Facebook! If you would like to register now, pease click here: Register

    Once registered please introduce yourself in our introduction thread which can be found here: Introduction Board


Lockard 23

The WWF/E Guru
Joined
Feb 10, 2012
Messages
6,691
Reaction score
1,927
Points
0
Age
37
Location
Union City, Tennessee
Just recently, WWE released their version of Mt. Rushmore, with four prominent faces on it. From left to right, there is Undertaker, Hulk Hogan, Steve Austin and John Cena. Personally, I felt Taker didn't belong. I know he's a huge legend and has the greatest gimmick and the greatest streak and his WWE career has lasted from the waning days of the Hulkamania era (which is the era that made the WWF into a national beast) all the way to now. But still, The Rock and Bruno Sammartino are objectively better picks for that fourth spot... The Rock for being neck in neck in every way with Austin during the Attitude Era, and Sammartino for being the "forefather of the WWE" and selling out Madsion Square Garden more times than anyone on earth.

Anyway, that out of the way, the topic is, if WWE were to make a Mt. Rushmore of WCW, and to a less important degree, ECW, who would be the four faces to represent these respective companies?

For WCW, anyone who knows anything about the company should instantly say Ric Flair and Sting. They're the two guys who are the franchise players, so to speak. As soon as you say Dubya-Cee-Dubya, you should automatically think of those two. Hulk Hogan would have to be the third. A guy who helped legitimize the company further, he gave them their first year in profit, their biggest PPV revenue ever, played a pivotal part in their huge two year run, gave them their two biggest matches (Hogan/Goldberg, Hogan/Sting) during that run, etc. So, he certainly deserve his spot. The fourth spot goes to who, Goldberg? Why not, because to this day, he's still a name that people recognize and was at one time (though a short period of time, which is completely on the company not knowing how to handle hot programs like Goldberg and the NWO, not him) on the level of Austin in 1998. People used to dream of Austin/Goldberg back then just as they did Hogan/Flair in the 80s.

As for ECW, I admit that I haven't seen a whole lot of ECW. I know all about their rise (and fall) and how they came to be, I know all about Paul Heyman and the main players and some of the main feuds and have even seen a few of the matches. But when ECW was on television every week, I paid no attention to it and don't have a real desire to go back and do so because it's not my thing. That said, I think I know enough to say that two of the faces on their Mt. Rushmore will certainly be Tazz and RVD. Sabu is probably a third. But who is the fourth? Sandman? I'll need other opinions here.

Anyway, if such a mountain were created in the image of WCW and ECW, that's how I'd see it. Opinions agreeing or disagreeing are welcome as always.
 

seabs

Walking the King’s Road
Joined
Dec 18, 2011
Messages
39,124
Reaction score
5,642
Points
118
Age
31
Location
God's Country, Sheffield UK
WCW

Sting - The Franchise player
Flair - He is JCP / WCW IMO
Hollywood Hogan - Without him WCW doesn't boom and have it's best day
Goldberg - An odd choice to some I'm sure but he was possibly their brightest star ever during his run in 98.

ECW

Heyman - Without him none of this happens, Vince should be on WWE's for similar reasons, same as Bisch up there maybe for Bill actually.
Sandman - Whenever anyone mentions ECW I think of his smashing himself open with a beer can.
Tommy Dreamer - The babyface of ECW, he emboddied the fighting spirit of the company with his bumps
Shane Douglas - Throwing down the NWA title made this companies personality what it was
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nano

Dolph'sZiggler

Biggest self-mark since Bret Hart
Joined
Feb 2, 2012
Messages
47,754
Reaction score
14,050
Points
0
Age
33
Agree on WCW.

ECW it's hard to leave off Taz or Van Dam or Raven or Sabu.. ECW was just too amazing. I guess I would take off Heyman for Raven. Raven to me was the greatest and most entertaining thing about ECW, and he had two long runs with the belt in the heyday of ECW. I think his feuds with Dreamer and Sandman are probably two of the best feuds in wrestling/ECW history.
 

seabs

Walking the King’s Road
Joined
Dec 18, 2011
Messages
39,124
Reaction score
5,642
Points
118
Age
31
Location
God's Country, Sheffield UK
RVD was never that big in oldschool ECW I believe, he was always tearing it up in the midcard but never really broke out ( I don't think he ever mainevented a PPV for them as an example, feel free to prove me wrong though) I'd class it more as putting Jericho on a WCW Mt Rushmore, great matches and great midcard reigns (both held TV titles I think) but not on that tier.
 

Nano

The Game
Technician
Joined
Feb 3, 2013
Messages
6,974
Reaction score
540
Points
0
Age
37
Location
Boston, MA, USA
Website
www.pheed.com
Dirk Diggler said:
WCW

Sting - The Franchise player
Flair - He is JCP / WCW IMO
Hollywood Hogan - Without him WCW doesn't boom and have it's best day
Goldberg - An odd choice to some I'm sure but he was possibly their brightest star ever during his run in 98.

ECW

Heyman - Without him none of this happens, Vince should be on WWE's for similar reasons, same as Bisch up there maybe for Bill actually.
Sandman - Whenever anyone mentions ECW I think of his smashing himself open with a beer can.
Tommy Dreamer - The babyface of ECW, he emboddied the fighting spirit of the company with his bumps
Shane Douglas - Throwing down the NWA title made this companies personality what it was

Can't add anything, this is it
 

Farooq

Chairwoman of The New Day
Joined
Jun 2, 2012
Messages
23,193
Reaction score
7,027
Points
0
Location
619
ECW:
Paul Heyman
The Sandman
Raven
Taz

Not sure about WCW so just put Ron Simmons with the WCW championship and we'll call it a day :eek:tunga:
 

Dolph'sZiggler

Biggest self-mark since Bret Hart
Joined
Feb 2, 2012
Messages
47,754
Reaction score
14,050
Points
0
Age
33
Dirk Diggler said:
RVD was never that big in oldschool ECW I believe, he was always tearing it up in the midcard but never really broke out ( I don't think he ever mainevented a PPV for them as an example, feel free to prove me wrong though) I'd class it more as putting Jericho on a WCW Mt Rushmore, great matches and great midcard reigns (both held TV titles I think) but not on that tier.

Ashley RVD was main eventing PPVs as soon as he got to the company in 1996. Well, not a real PPV but the equivalent that the company had in 96

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hardcore_Heaven#1996

He was on the poster of their first real PPV in 97.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECW_Barely_Legal

It was often said that during RVD's run as TV champ that that belt was actually more prestigious at the time because of how over RVD was and how quality his work was. He wasn't "main eventing" PPVs in the sense that he wasn't going on last, but he was getting 2nd bill and he was the main draw on the show from 98-2000, at least. It was suggested that Heyman wanted to have RVD win a unification match with the ECW & TV Title before RVD broke his ankle and had to vacate his title after a 700+ day run.
 

arianna

The Showoff
Joined
Sep 1, 2012
Messages
2,161
Reaction score
24
Points
0
Location
USA
Dirk Diggler said:
WCW

Sting - The Franchise player
Flair - He is JCP / WCW IMO
Hollywood Hogan - Without him WCW doesn't boom and have it's best day
Goldberg - An odd choice to some I'm sure but he was possibly their brightest star ever during his run in 98.

ECW

Heyman - Without him none of this happens, Vince should be on WWE's for similar reasons, same as Bisch up there maybe for Bill actually.
Sandman - Whenever anyone mentions ECW I think of his smashing himself open with a beer can.
Tommy Dreamer - The babyface of ECW, he emboddied the fighting spirit of the company with his bumps
Shane Douglas - Throwing down the NWA title made this companies personality what it was

Agreed.
 

seabs

Walking the King’s Road
Joined
Dec 18, 2011
Messages
39,124
Reaction score
5,642
Points
118
Age
31
Location
God's Country, Sheffield UK
Dolph'sZiggler said:
Ashley RVD was main eventing PPVs as soon as he got to the company in 1996. Well, not a real PPV but the equivalent that the company had in 96

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hardcore_Heaven#1996

He was on the poster of their first real PPV in 97.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECW_Barely_Legal

It was often said that during RVD's run as TV champ that that belt was actually more prestigious at the time because of how over RVD was and how quality his work was. He wasn't "main eventing" PPVs in the sense that he wasn't going on last, but he was getting 2nd bill and he was the main draw on the show from 98-2000, at least. It was suggested that Heyman wanted to have RVD win a unification match with the ECW & TV Title before RVD broke his ankle and had to vacate his title after a 700+ day run.

:obama: who'd have flunk it Bob Van Dam on a poster for a PPV.

Yeah I knew he was planning to unify the titles in 2000 I think (it's mentioned on his wiki page) he was bigger than I thought he was, no idea why he didn't through the main title on him during their struggles in 99 if he was drawing so much though, just seems odd you know? Then again ECW was that kind of place that did things differently.

Even with this info I can't include him in my 4 most influencial people in the companies history list sadly, I don't know alot about ECW but I can't justify him over any of the other guys from what I do know.
 

Dolph'sZiggler

Biggest self-mark since Bret Hart
Joined
Feb 2, 2012
Messages
47,754
Reaction score
14,050
Points
0
Age
33
I don't like putting Heyman on the "Mt. Rushmore" anymore than I like the idea of Vince on WWE. It should be wrestlers
 

Aids Johnson

The Beast
Champion
Joined
May 25, 2012
Messages
44,717
Reaction score
8,455
Points
0
Disco inferno, big poppa pump, Konan, and Bischoff are WCW and ECW is just 4 different Taz Faces.
 

Tchman58

Jobber
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
120
Reaction score
21
Points
0
ECW: Terry Funk, Paul Heyman, Tommy Dreamer...those three for sure IMO. The fourth could be tazz/rvd/Shane Douglas. Don't think Sabu deserves it anymore than new jack or sandman. They are great gimmick type guys but the company could easily survive without them.

WCW: Really depends on if you count the NWA time period or not. Regardless I think flair and sting are obvious. I'd prob put Ted Turner on it. And then Hollywood hogan as the 4th.
 

Lockard 23

The WWF/E Guru
Joined
Feb 10, 2012
Messages
6,691
Reaction score
1,927
Points
0
Age
37
Location
Union City, Tennessee
Forgot all about Dreamer. I don't like the idea of putting non-wrestlers on the Rushmore though, not Vince or Heyman or Ted Turner/Bischoff.
 

Tchman58

Jobber
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
120
Reaction score
21
Points
0
Goldberg doesn't deserve it. He was relevant for 18-24 months. That does not make him worthy of a spot on wcw Mount Rushmore