I think GardsJr was a bit small, so I couldn't really see much of it, as Kevin said he's knew to GFX, and I think Gards is as well so they weren't going to be the greatest graphics ever, but they both gave it a good go and did very well for newcomers. My vote goes to kevin because I liked how he fit in the background pictures of Punk. The front picture of Punk was very creative and it worked kinda well. I don't think red is the colour for Punk though however. Maybe experiment with other colours and effects next time. Also I don't think Punk would have an Old style of text, because he has the Straight-Edge gimmick. Gards I think I would have voted for you if I was able to see more of it.