Official Edge Return Discussion

  • Welcome to "The New" Wrestling Smarks Forum!

    I see that you are not currently registered on our forum. It only takes a second, and you can even login with your Facebook! If you would like to register now, pease click here: Register

    Once registered please introduce yourself in our introduction thread which can be found here: Introduction Board


noumenon

Guest
This has popped up in a lot of different threads, so it's pretty evident... we all miss Edge. So with rumors going around that we could see Edge make his return as early as this Sunday at the Royal Rumble, let's discuss Edge's much anticipated return.
Just a few questions though...
-How do you think the fans will respond to the return of the Rated R Superstar? Decent face pop? Monstrous reaction rivaling HHH's first quad tear? Some lingering heel heat?
-Are the WWE fans ready to embrace a face Edge? And if so, how should the character be handled?
-Where do you see ending up in 2010?


As for me I think Edge will no doubt receive a great reaction upon his return, especially if it has something to do with screwing Jericho out of a victory of some sort. However, I'm just a little worried about a surprise return for Edge. WWE has done this so many times and it causes the majority of fans to miss their return as it's usually done on a PPV. I was really hoping for a slow build return for Edge to get the fans pumped up and really build suspense that much more. Had this been the hotter WWE crowd we knew years back I really wouldn't doubt that Edge's return ovation could possibly rival that of HHH's. With the seemingly cooled down crowd reactions over the past few years I'm really not sure how raucous of a response he'll receive.

As far as a face Edge, yeah I think we're more than ready to see it. The guy has been heel for five years. In those five years he's proved he can run with the best of them and be a top heel. Although he wasn't quite stale yet, you could tell hints of the crowd wanting to like Edge. As one of the grittier characters in the WWE, much like Orton he was starting to get scattered pops and chants. I think the balance needs to be perfect with his face character though. He definitely needs to retain some of his raunchy, underhanded techniques that he used so well in the Rated R gimmick, to drop that completely would be a crime. No one is going to be a goody goody Edge at this point, nor are they going to want to see it.

I think 2010 will be a true telling year for Edge. His face turn could be a true trial for his character and really cement his spot as a versatile top star in the company. Aside from the obvious feud with Jericho, which I think could possibly turn out to be a virtual highlight real of 2010, I'm really hoping for a move back to RAW for Edge. I think if he does indeed stay face for a while there are some pretty good things he could do back on RAW. A much anticipated re-hash of his feud with Orton, Sheamus, (hopefully a heel) HHH at some point.
 

straight_edge76

Guest
Honestly, much like any higly anticipated return I could see nothing but a huge pop for Edge. Honestly, I believe the Edge face turn was long due, from Wrestlemania on I got the feeling that the crowd was waiting for an excuse to start cheering Edge, If I am not mistaken right before his injury he started getting some scattered cheers much like Orton, just not as many. I honestly as much as I do not want to see it is a Jericho/Edge feud. I see Edge getting Jericho either eliminated from the Rumble match (If he does return that early) or cost him some sort of championship match.

But honestly I would much rather prefer it to have his return hyped for weeks much like HHH's return a few summers ago. With Jericho cutting some awesome promos talking about how Edge "Screwed" him for weeks building up to a awesome return by The Rated R Superstar and the ensuing confrontation/feud.
 

Airfixx

Guest
^^^WDF? ...Why would you not want to see an Edge/Jericho fued?

I share the same concerns as Noumenon... Lack of build, typical 'surprise' return etc. Plus, why would all the kids cheer his return? ...They'll remember him as the guy that screwed Taker, Jeff & Cena for the last 2 years. I really hope the don't bring him back on Sunday and actually build towards a return with, vignettes, Jericho (if a fued between them is indeed the plan) cutting promo's etc.,

Previously, I found Edge a rather uninteresting character as a singles face - I am intrigued to see what kind of impact he can make when he does return. I just prey they don't remove all semblance of his character and churn out generic babyface #1,254,505.
 

straight_edge76

Guest
mainly for the reason of there really wasn't any real reason for one other then the promo(s) (I can't remember if there was more then one tbh) about Edge "taking the easy way out" but as I started thinking about it honestly it would be the only way to really give him a "comeback feud" and not a "Hey! I'm back!' sort of feel to it.
 

noumenon

Guest
I brought up the same point originally that there really wasn't a whole lot of ground to go off of for a feud between the two. But you know what, what feud in WWE today does?
The promos would be phenomenal, amazing matches...so fuck it.
 

straight_edge76

Guest
I brought up the same point originally that there really wasn't a whole lot of ground to go off of for a feud between the two. But you know what, what feud in WWE today does?
The promos would be phenomenal, amazing matches...so fuck it.

Impossible to argue with that.
 

Millzy Pt. 2

Active Member
Joined
Nov 15, 2007
Messages
1,517
Reaction score
0
Points
36
Age
32
Location
Erie, PA
But would anybody be expecting a swerve between Edge and Christian once Edge makes his return? For some reason, I think a comeback storyline for Edge with Christian in the mix very interesting.
 

straight_edge76

Guest
That is something I could see the WWE doing. I am all for it if it can be booked correctly.
 

noumenon

Guest
No Edge and Christian, stop it.
So then everyone can bitch "What about Christians singles career? Where's HIS title shots..blah blah blah".

Give them another year to see if they actually want to push Christian any higher up the card. If not, then yeah... go ahead with Edge and Christian.
 

straight_edge76

Guest
If Edge & Christan do reunite I think It would feel awkward being that his character now is sooooo different then the Character when they were a team. He has evolved so much more then Christan. Not that I do not like Christan's character its just that Edge has evolved so much more, he went from Mr. 5 Second pose to The Rated R Superstar. What did Christan become? Captain Charisma? Not much change. imo
 

noumenon

Guest
Look at what HHH became post-DX. Yet he still went back and goofed it up with Shawn.
 

Millzy Pt. 2

Active Member
Joined
Nov 15, 2007
Messages
1,517
Reaction score
0
Points
36
Age
32
Location
Erie, PA
Look at what HHH became post-DX. Yet he still went back and goofed it up with Shawn.
Yep, and WWE bookers constantly discussed about the face turn for Edge long ago. And I don't think the Edge (face turn) hype still hasn't faded away either.

I couldn't see Edge & Christian as heels again because Christian's Captain Charisma gimmick. I actually do see the Rated R Superstar as a possible face for some reason.
 

noumenon

Guest
Yep, and WWE bookers constantly discussed about the face turn for Edge long ago. And I don't think the Edge (face turn) hype still hasn't faded away either.

I couldn't see Edge & Christian as heels again because Christian's Captain Charisma gimmick. I actually do see the Rated R Superstar as a possible face for some reason.

You think you could get me into one of those booking meetings with you? :p
 

Millzy Pt. 2

Active Member
Joined
Nov 15, 2007
Messages
1,517
Reaction score
0
Points
36
Age
32
Location
Erie, PA
You think you could get me into one of those booking meetings with you? :p
I'll break into the booking meeting as long as you give me a crowbar or something, and you can do the talking Mr. Noumenon.
 

MizMasta3000

Guest
This thread is genius. I am at the point where when Edge comes back I will mark my ass off. I miss him so much and SD, even with Jericho and Punk, is lacking real badly.