Miss WrestleMania: According to Dave Meltzer

[Barry Poppins]

This is gonna be one of those lists where I go back on the history of every Women's match, or every match involving women, and then we calculate who had the best average match, according to WON's star rating. So without further ado, let's get into it.

Part 1: The Matches

WrestleMania I
- Wendi Richter d. Leilani Kai (c) *

WrestleMania II
- Fabulous Moolah (c) d. Velvet McIntyre DUD

WrestleMania VI
- Dusty Rhodes & Sapphire d. Randy Savage & Sensational Sherri *1/2

WrestleMania X
- Bam Bam Bigelow & Luna Vachon d. Doink & Dink *3/4
- Alundra Blayze (c) d. Leilani Kai *1/4

WrestleMania XIV
- Sable & Marc Mero d. Goldust & Luna Vachon ***

WrestleMania XV
- Sable (c) d. Tori -**

WrestleMania 2000
- Terri Runnels d. The Kat -*

WrestleMania X-Seven
- Chyna d. Ivory (c) *

WrestleMania X-8
- Jazz (c) d. Trish Stratus & Lita -*

WrestleMania XIX
- Trish Stratus d. Victoria (c) & Jazz **1/4

WrestleMania XX
- Torrie Wilson & Sable d. Miss Jackie & Stacey Keibler 1/4*
- Victoria (c) d. Molly Holly *

WrestleMania 21
- Trish Stratus (c) d. Christy Hemme DUD

WrestleMania 22
- The Boogeyman d. Booker T & Sharmell -*
- Mickie James d. Trish Stratus (c) **
- Torrie Wilson d. Candice Michelle DUD

WrestleMania 23
- Melina (c) d. Ashley DUD

WrestleMania XXIV
- Beth Phoenix & Melina d. Maria Kanellis & Ashley 1/4*

WrestleMania 25th Anniversary
- "Miss WrestleMania" Battle Royale DUD

WrestleMania XXVI
- Alicia Fox, LayCool, Maryse, & Vickie Guerero d. Beth Phoenix, Gail Kim, Eve Torres, Kelly Kelly, and Mickie James DUD
WrestleMania XXVII
- John Morrison, Snooki, & Trish Stratus d. Dolph Ziggler & LayCool *

WrestleMania XXVIII
- Kelly Kelly & Maria Menounos d. Beth Phoenix & Eve Torres *1/2

WrestleMania XXX
- Vickie Guerrero Invitational Battle Royale *1/4

WrestleMania 31
- AJ Lee & Paige d. The Bella Twins **1/2

WrestleMania 32
- Team Total Divas d. Team B.A.D & Blonde **1/4
- Charlotte d. Sasha Banks & Becky Lynch ****

WrestleMania 33
- Bayley (c) d. Charlotte, Nia Jax & Sasha Banks ***1/4
- Nikki Bella & John Cena d. Maryse & The Miz **1/4
- Naomi d. Alexa Bliss (c), Becky Lynch, Carmella, Mickie James, & Natalya *1/2

WrestleMania 34
- Women's Battle Royale *1/2
- Charlotte (c) d. Asuka ****
- Kurt Angle & Ronda Rousey d. Triple H & Stephanie McMahon ****1/4
- Nia Jax d. Alexa Bliss (c) **3/4

WrestleMania 35
- Women's Battle Royale **1/4
- The IIconics d. Boss & Hug Connection (c), Nia Jax & Tamina, and Beth Phoenix & Natalya *1/4
- Becky Lynch d. Ronda Rousey (c) & Charlotte (c) ***

WrestleMania 36

* Meltzer opted to not rate any of the matches for WrestleMania 36 (due to COVID).

WrestleMania 37
- Tag-Team Turmoil * (Based on Average of the Segments)
- Bianca Belair d. Sasha Banks (c) ****
- Nia Jax & Shayna Baszler (c) d. Natalya & Tamina **1/4
- Rhea Ripley d. Asuka (c) ***3/4

WrestleMania 38
- Bianca Belair d. Becky Lynch (c) ****1/2
- Charlotte (c) d. Ronda Rousey **
- Sasha Banks & Naomi d. Carmella & Zelina Vega (c), Liv Morgan & Rhea Ripley, and Shayna Baszler & Natalya **1/2

WrestleMania 39
- Trish Stratus, Lita, & Becky Lynch d. Damage CTRL **3/4
- Rhea Ripley d. Charlotte (c) ****3/4
- Ronda Rousey & Shayna Baszler d. Liv Morgan & Raquel Rodriguez, Natalya & Shotzi, and Chelsea Green & Sonya Deville **1/2
- Bianca Belair (c) d. Asuka ***3/4

WrestleMania 40
- Rhea Ripley (c) d. Becky Lynch ****1/4
- Jade Cargill, Bianca Belair, & Naomi d. Damage CTRL **
- Bayley d. Iyo Sky (c) ****1/2

WrestleMania 41
- Jade Cargill d. Naomi **
- Tiffany Stratton (c) d. Charlotte *3/4
- Iyo Sky (c) d. Bianca Belair & Rhea Ripley *****
- Lyra Valkyrie & Becky Lynch d. Liv Morgan & Raquel Rodriguez (c) **

 

[Samoa Looch]

Well... one quick look makes it seem like it's gonna end up being Bianca

 

[Barry Poppins]

Here's the current rating list atm:

Bianca Belair - 3.4 Avg
Charlotte - 3.3 Avg
Asuka - 3.15 Avg
Sasha Banks - 2.7 Avg

 

[Chris]

It would be more fluid especially for this year's Mania and they have the 5 minute minimum limitation as well, but I would be curious in this compared to cagematch ratings as well

 

[Sky]

Here's the current rating list atm:

Bianca Belair - 3.4 Avg
Charlotte - 3.3 Avg
Asuka - 3.15 Avg
Sasha Banks - 2.7 Avg

That WOMBAR feels like it's dragging everyone down

 

[Samoa Looch]

Guess only Rhea is "better" than Bianca with round about a 4.0 avg