errrrgh well, several things here..
1- the psd is too blurry and the darkness you tried to add was added in a wrong proportion.
2- Make sure you dont add a psd that has a cut in the arms! T_T
3- The font really killed it.
if you want me to rate it.. im sorry it doesnt get more than 3/10 tbh with you mate.
good effort, keep up the hard work.