imo they are 2 grainy and me personally I hate the grainy look, also the ben one had a better psd ,although i think u cut his hair a lil, around his shoulders/collar there is still a lil white trim from w/e u cut him out of. and if they were both about half the size they are id like it more. Lastly please change the font.
Not a bad sig but you have done alot better. 6/10