LC12: Chriss v. -PHENOM-

[The_King]

Chriss' Entry

-PHENOM-'s Entry

When voting, please clearly specify who you are voting for. Support for your vote is greatly appreciated but not required.
The battle will close on Monday July 16, 2012 at 11:59 P.M. (Central Time)
Good luck!​

 

[Andrew]

1. Chriss
2. -PHENOM-

 

[The_King]

Chriss: The background work is awesome, pretty much flawless and really appealing. Unfortunately, the render is just low quality, and the text isn't the best. If you would've dropped the render and played with the text, this would've been hard to beat.
-PHENOM-: Background work is awesome, but the main focus- the girls- is so off. The weird effect on their skin is super unappealing. You probably should've brought them in front of the effect. Text is just okay. Plus, it doesn't seem too clothing-centric, instead seeming to be two girls on a poster with a bikini text slapped on to fit the theme.

My vote goes to Chriss.

 

[Mr. Krueger]

Chriss - Great banner. As King said, its kinda low resolution, otherwise great piece. I on the other hand, like the text though.

Phenom - While I do get it that when you are designing for a bikini clothing line, the attention automatically gets driven away from the clothing itself and onto the girls, however knowing that we had the option to go for any clothing line, the focus could have been better picked. It's a better banner overall IMO, but doesn't go well in the theme described.

Vote: Chriss

 

[Defiant]

Voting for Chriss if only because Phenom's doesn't really hit the theme. Personally I like Phenom's more overall though.

 

[Heisenberg]

What Defiant said. Sorry PHENOM.

Chriss gets my vote.

 

[Lub]

Chriss gets my vote here. Great piece -PHENOM- as always, but I just don't like the effects you put there and as King said, those girls are "off".

 

[The_King]

The battle is now closed.
Chriss (6) def. -PHENOM- (0)
Congrats to Chriss!