Considering if Benoit came back to life he'd probably just be arrested; I'm going to go with either Eddie Guerrero or Shawn Michaels. I'd probably go with Eddie since I don't actually want Shawn to un-retire and be one of those millions of wrestlers, but I do like the prospect of Shawn vs. Punk actually happening (all-time favorite vs. current favorite; always awesome idea) however that's not enough to take him over Eddie.