Again this is an OPINION!!!
For my money, its Ricky Steamboat. He was the first guy that I really gave a crap about in the ring, and it was mostly for his matches. Granted, I didn't know anything about wrestling back then, but when I saw Steamboat it just looked great. The chops looked stiff, the armdrags were flawless, he just looked so smooth in the ring and could have a good match with just about anyone.