The background is good just like much of your work over here. But, the main PSD of AJ Styles is totally unclear man. It's blurry, windy whatever it's not clear at all and that spoils the look of this signature.
You should have made AJ the focus point of the signature and used some other balance over there instead of the yellowish-brown of the background. The text isn't clear as well, looks as if it's faded into the background or maybe it's just the brown color which is there too much.
The text should be eye-catching and more attractive, maybe a different color would have worked. Overall it's "Ok" work nonetheless but not "good" because you're Wrestling Station and I have seen much much better GFX you 6.5/10