Roman Reigns... oh wait, you said for NOT liking.
I have NEVER understood the appeal of Randy Orton. I don't think he is charismatic. His matches all seem exactly the same to me and I hate that STUPID DDT with his opponents feet on the second rope. Everyone always says how perfect and fluid his movements are, but if I have about 5 or 6 movements, I'd be pretty good at them. He may possibly be the most overrated wrestler of all time.
John Cena. This is a mixed thing. Back in 2006, I didn't have a problem with not liking Cena. Hell, I am from Chicago which is probably the city that hates Cena the most. HOWEVER, the generation that was first exposed to Cena when they began watching wrestling defends him as if he is the greatest thing of all time. He's not even close. Just because he was WWE's go to guy for 10 years doesn't make him great. It makes him a guy who wanted a steady paycheck for 10 years. I would put him as the most mediocre top star in WWE ever... more mediocre than Backlund even. He wouldn't go on my wrestling Mount Rushmore... he wouldn't be considered. Although I LOVE his work before his first world championship and I love his work since he has fallen out of the main event, for the peak of his career, I found him BORING and MEDIOCRE. And no amount of arguing will every change my mind on that.
EC III. Sorry, overrated. Annoying. Crappy wrestler. Horrible charisma. Had no business EVER being in a main event much less holding a world title. Blech.
I like this thread. How about 3 wrestlers you may get bashed for liking?