2024 PWI 250

[Hidden Blaze]

Athena at 10 is criminally low.

 

[Chris]

I'd have def put Athena over Willow and Mariah, but I'm not really too pressed about it bc she had a bit of a lesser year compared to last. She was still dominant, but didn't feel like she had as many TV defenses either this time.

I'd also probably have Sarree over Steph but that's very minor lol

 

[Hidden Blaze]

Also shocked Roxanne didn’t make top 10 tbh.

But I’m very happy Toni is #1

 

[Chris]

Oh yeah Roxanne not being there is crazy since she's doing the whole dream match champion defenses and NXT men's are ranked high most of the time

 

[Dale]

Roxy not being in the Top10 at the absolute worst brings up some serious question marks

 

[Bad News Booty]

Was she out did a part of the year or am I imagining’s that?

 

[Chris]

Was she out did a part of the year or am I imagining’s that?

Not 2024 that I remember but I don't really remember her last few months of 23, also not sure what the date range for this one is lol I assume it's not the same as the 500 since it's released later

 

[Hidden Blaze]

I saw someone say June 23 to June 24. But I’m not sure. Couldn’t be much later and ending starting point. But nah, I just looked. She was there at the end of 2023. So she definitely was there during the whole thing.

 

[Chris]

I saw someone say June 23 to June 24. But I’m not sure. Couldn’t be much later and ending starting point. But nah, I just looked. She was there at the end of 2023. So she definitely was there during the whole thing.

That's what the 500 is, I wasn't sure for this one. I'd def not have Mariah quite that high if Wembley isn't even in the period. She had a big winning streak going prior but champions weight should probably have Roxanne and Athena over her

 

[Dale]

Just embedding the pic so its easier to read the criteria etc. Evaluation period it says is from October 23 to end of September 24​

 

[Chris]

Seems their thought process this year was just NXT and ROH not being valued as high then. It fluctuates every year really anyway, I assume the committee people voting are rarely the same too

 

[Crocker]

Athena not being on regular TV is killing her


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Cwalker]

I do think if she was on TV more she'd be top 5

 

[Chris]

I don't because everyone hates when ROH titles are shown on AEW TV and if she wasn't ROH champion and just getting a regular push then she's fighting with Mariah and Willow for spots lol she's only 10 bc she's ROH Champion generating her points. Her reign would also suck a lot more if she was on AEW TV. The men's ROH champions are and their belts are just props, absolutely useless until they remember they work ROH come PPV time. The women's titles actually being exclusive is the only thing keeping ROH watchable rn

 

[Bad News Booty]

I think they meant if ROH had a proper show