WS Christmas Mafia 2022

[Chris]

Oh i guess so that's what your list essentially says lol

I kinda see that too, I think scum smark really likes winning a little too tho FWIW and that means he'd be less likely to do something like that as an owner

*winning as scum not winning a little lmao not sure how that happened

 

[John McHenry]

My problem with it was more him giving himself a reason to not read her entirely

Yeah I think that's just poor choice of words. If we somehow got good indications of Juice not being town he'd go that way but as a lynch to have a lynch I think he's claiming he wouldn't do it?

 

[Poyser]

Also I will say chris your analysis seems SOLID so far and gives me a town lean

tho im sure im underestimating you due to you being too much of a coward to play these days

 

[Chris]

I could def see him do it as S/T but yeah you're right, no way they're S/S

My problem with it was more him giving himself a reason to not read her entirely

I don't really think that's true tho bc whether he said that or not, if the juice wagon got momentum and looked like it was happening he'd be forced to give some kind of town or scum lead or would draw a lot more suspicion on himself if he refused so if he's hoping to not have to read her entirely then thats just a poor mistake on his part. I think it's more likely he's setting up an "I told you so" if she flips town and he'd probably end up town reading her himself before that happened

 

[Chris]

Also I will say chris your analysis seems SOLID so far and gives me a town lean

tho im sure im underestimating you due to you being too much of a coward to play these days

I really don't have the time I used to nowadays lol playing at work is harder and I'm legit running late rn bc I've been playing

 

[Poyser]

Yeah I think that's just poor choice of words. If we somehow got good indications of Juice not being town he'd go that way but as a lynch to have a lynch I think he's claiming he wouldn't do it?

What Im saying is, he is coming out and saying, Im definitely not lynching Juice D1 because thats lazy and predictable.
The thing is, he is taking that stance entirely out of principle, which means he doesnt have to say whether he actually thinks she's town or whether he thinks she's sus. He's taken an entirely mechanical stance, rather than a play based one.

 

[Poyser]

I don't really think that's true tho bc whether he said that or not, if the juice wagon got momentum and looked like it was happening he'd be forced to give some kind of town or scum lead or would draw a lot more suspicion on himself if he refused so if he's hoping to not have to read her entirely then thats just a poor mistake on his part. I think it's more likely he's setting up an "I told you so" if she flips town and he'd probably end up town reading her himself before that happened

Down the line sure, but I was more talking about in the moment. He shut the wagon down but he did it without saying he thinks shes town if that makes sense lol

Im not saying I def think smark is scum for it or anything btw, but that rubbed me up the wrong way. Your point that he'd think that would draw too much attention to himself has merit

 

[Poyser]

I really don't have the time I used to nowadays lol playing at work is harder and I'm legit running late rn bc I've been playing

I've been there lol. Lost count of the amount of times Ive been like hey I've got 5 mins before I need to leave, lets have a quick read of some posts oh whoops its been 20 minutes shit

 

[John McHenry]

I really don't have the time I used to nowadays lol playing at work is harder and I'm legit running late rn bc I've been playing

As much crap as I gave you about it my last two games. The last game, and I assume this game will be tricky for me too because of the time of year. I'm just more capable cause I hate my job lol

 

[Chris]

Down the line sure, but I was more talking about in the moment. He shut the wagon down but he did it without saying he thinks shes town if that makes sense lol

Im not saying I def think smark is scum for it or anything btw, but that rubbed me up the wrong way. Your point that he'd think that would draw too much attention to himself has merit

Yeah in that exact moment, but if it doesn't even keep him from having to give an opinion through Day 1 it's not a good move lol but fair point on it shutting down the wagon, if it never materialized then yeah he wouldn't need to give that opinion either

 

[Poyser]

As much crap as I gave you about it my last two games. The last game, and I assume this game will be tricky for me too because of the time of year. I'm just more capable cause I hate my job lol

Yeah its gonna be quite hard for everyone to remain super active especially as it starts getting to the business part of this week so I wouldn't worry about it. I know full well Im not gonna be super active at all from about friday to mid next week cos if I started spending loads of family time on my phone I'd be in deep shit lmao. We are more understanding in xmas mafia!

 

[Chris]

I'll probably be more active when I'm with family tbh except for when I'm making the long drive there and back lol

 

[John McHenry]

Yeah Unfortunately we don't get any time off apparently and I don't start accruing sick or vacation days until feb. Friday her family christmas day her family (already did my side). So who knows how active I'll be while with family lol.

 

[Mandalorian]

So I know I mentioned it myself, but does Tweet come in as scum to just put eyes on himself like that?

Surely he’d know him coming in to be the second vote very early on Grim would have people looking at him. It’s not like that wagon was actually going to go anywhere.

It just seems like a very strange play on Tweet’s part at best, to be honest. I don’t think it’s enough in isolation to put a vote on Tweet myself, but I wouldn’t mind some clarification on why he voted for Grim.

 

[Chris]

Yeah I'd like more from tweet, it was a weird vote bc it was just that, only a vote. I was sketchy of Barry at the time myself too before Poyser made me realize that town Barry always seems sketchy to me and then I thought back about how our non-mafia conversations feel the same way lol