"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Baldrick]

I take this to mean that you’d see people following my vote on you to be suspicious? If that’s the case then why am I not suspicious?

Are you really asking that? You've been on me a fair bit so it's natural to expect you to vote for me.

Why would I say you are suspicious in this scenario?

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

 

[Poyser]

Are you really asking that? You've been on me a fair bit so it's natural to expect you to vote for me.

Why would I say you are suspicious in this scenario?

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

Was just wondering where you’d draw the line between when a vote on you would be suspicious and when it wouldn’t.

 

[Poyser]

I think scum. Coming out swinging so hard is typically a sign of fear. Towns people really only need to probe and inquire because they know they're innocent..

Not sure that adds up, would you not think someone that’s fearful would rather try and blend into the background rather than draw attention to themselves?

 

[Baldrick]

Was just wondering where you’d draw the line between when a vote on you would be suspicious and when it wouldn’t.

Wouldn't be suspicious on those with reasoning like you have. Any sheep votes without validity i'd be probing further.

I'll add when I say validity i'd expect someone not to just echo anothers post.

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

 

[John McHenry]

Not sure that adds up, would you not think someone that’s fearful would rather try and blend into the background rather than draw attention to themselves?

Maybe it's too many cop shows those in fear get erratic make dumb choices and lash out

 

[Poyser]

don’t agree with you in a mafia sense, but I get the feeling your thoughts are genuine

 

[Canadian Dragon]

For what it's worth I think you are town.

The lack of any kind of followinv votes on me or the others with votes leads me to think the scum are laying low at the moment, so the more active guys are looking better to me.

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

juice is that you?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Christ that catchup was heaven after the champ games where I woke up to 500+ posts every single morning

I kinda liked Jeff's entrance, though he disappeared fast so Im not really gonna give him a cookie for it, but it's encouraging! Seemed comfortable
Like I said I think Tweet trying to figure out who that guy was is *slightly* rand>town because I don't really see him giving a shit as scum. Felt to me like he was at least putting some time into figuring out who the guy was

Sister Abigail is my first proper townlean, thought they had a strong entrance and tried to cut through the bullshit

Not really liking Baldrick's entrance and seemed like he was just trying to make inane conversation for the sake of it. That question to Jeff was a load of nothing lol, what was he asking if he was "hunting"? Dude literally just asked how many games you'd played before

vote baldrick

Smark has been pretty underwhelming as well, inb4 "OMG I DONT DO ANYTHING ON D1 YOU SHOULD KNOW THIS"

ok so i went back to see the baldrick stuff as i knew i had missed context.. I agree with you actually and had a weird "im not sure how to even answer that" moment with that reply of his to me, to the point where I just didn't answer and moved on. I also agree that was a generous use of the word hunt, I was more just being polite and ya I suppose assessing the new player base but it's not like I followed up with some grilling afterwards. interesting

 

[Baldrick]

juice is that you?

Who is juice?

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Who is juice?

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

it's a bad joke, don't worry about it tbh I'm just popping myself there

 

[Captain Holt]

Baldrick is tough to read but this feels like his town game. I think you might ne tunnelimg a bit Poyser, but if youre town and he IS scum, rattling him isnt a bad idea.

RedDragon reminds me of Wang with the way he posts.

Sister Abigail seems the most sus to me thus far, plus Man seems oddly reserved.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

I kind of get the sense that Baldrick is trying to convey confidence regarding any votes towards him as an opportunity to analyze them. That would obviously be a towny thing, esp if he had reasons to be confident in his claim. With 50 games under his belt however I'd assume he would know how to convey that as scum as well when under pressure.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

don’t agree with you in a mafia sense, but I get the feeling your thoughts are genuine

who are you talking to btw, there's 2 guys you were grilling and you didnt quote

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Baldrick is tough to read but this feels like his town game. I think you might ne tunnelimg a bit Poyser, but if youre town and he IS scum, rattling him isnt a bad idea.

RedDragon reminds me of Wang with the way he posts.

Sister Abigail seems the most sus to me thus far, plus Man seems oddly reserved.

interesting post

first sentence is saying a lot of things. So I'm going to ask you something: How do YOU read poyser? the way you worded the second sentence intrigues me

How do I remind you of Wang and how does he play elsewhere? Here he usually just posts 3 times and disappears forever.

What about Sister Abigail felt reserved?

 

[Poyser]

Baldrick is tough to read but this feels like his town game. I think you might ne tunnelimg a bit Poyser, but if youre town and he IS scum, rattling him isnt a bad idea.

RedDragon reminds me of Wang with the way he posts.

Sister Abigail seems the most sus to me thus far, plus Man seems oddly reserved.

How would you describe both his town and his scum games?