Peaky Blinders Mafia - Game Thread

[Showtime]

the chimp situation makes negative sense.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

the chimp situation makes negative sense.

Kinda like the player himself.

 

[PHEN0M]

The Virgin claim was all-time.

 

[Doddsy]

how is that a horseshit reason?

it's literally the reasoning used last time when everyone was dogpiling mitch and it was right then too. if everyone is jumping on the same person and calling them scum on day 1 they're probably not scum.

I don't much agree with the bottom part, I don't think Tweet was dogpiled, in fact their was almost a conscious move away from Tweet as a direction once he hit like 4 votes on to Chimp.

I still have reservations over CP particularly too.

Also @Showtime one thing re: tweet - what you’re saying about everyone saying he’s scum isn’t really true - pretty sure Phenom at the very least thinks he’s town, and I imagine there’s a lot of players with no stated position (Haza, big man, Doddsy, CP iirc, probably more)

this much is more true at least, but no one also supported or defended him at all either(aside from myself).

I had a stated position on Tweet, I actually spent a good chunk of time voting for him

 

[Doddsy]

I’m not feeling Barry is scum. He usually tries to make moves and honestly Barry would probably try to push me if he was scum. Scum Barry wouldn’t care about millergate.

What's the basis of this? Is this a frequent thing?

what groundwork

and how am i scum with chimp?

I'm assuming he's saying you're scum with Chimp because Chimp said Magic has to be town during his slipping

see I like this post and I want to believe sky is consciously trying to play better

I do too but that doesn't mean she's town wasn't she scum recently when she played well?

I don't feel like Doddsy has contributed enough to really have anyone reading him town.

Big Man has been hit and miss and I believe he's mostly hid in the background.

Chimp likely slipped

And I think Darth might be indy.

The Rugrat town read is based off the fact he's playing like he did two games ago when I kept thinking he was scum but was town. So I'm going with my gut and trusting that Rugrat is town this game.

No. Laws of probability make me think a non-contributive Doddsy is more likely to be scum than town.

One could be bussing the other to look good, so no, it doesn't affect my reads. But if we were to lynch, Big Man over Doddsy first.

Lethal seems to be in it for himself and is playing for self-preservation mostly. Acting like he's doing something but not actually saying anything to make himself go unnoticed.

All three are POE to me. Would go along and lynch if the majority of the game wants it.

Also Haza can eat shit.

I'm confused by these statements. Why am I non-contributive? Literally all of my posts have been related to the game, I was actively pushing Tweet and Chimp during day one? It's almost as if you haven't read my posts?

Also what do you mean all 3 are POE, its night 1?

 

[Bobby Barrows]

What's the basis of this? Is this a frequent thing?


I'm assuming he's saying you're scum with Chimp because Chimp said Magic has to be town during his slipping


I do too but that doesn't mean she's town wasn't she scum recently when she played well?



I'm confused by these statements. Why am I non-contributive? Literally all of my posts have been related to the game, I was actively pushing Tweet and Chimp during day one? It's almost as if you haven't read my posts?

Considering you only have 26 posts and none of them have stood out to me, should be a sign of what I mean.

 

[RDK]

Ooo I dont really like Doddsy's posts at all

 

[Rugrat]

This is a poor series of posts from Haza, blatantly ignored the question and just took a shot at Odo instead

It’s not a good look but it seems like non-contributing town.

I guess it reminds how Flay would be abrasive as town but would lose all the obnoxiousness and bravado as scum

 

[Doddsy]

what do you mean? you mentioned him saying he intentionally bit on the bait and sounded skeptical about it. doesn't that mean you don't believe it was intentional?

it's not true though, at least not recent times I've been scum (not counting when im indy ). maybe a while ago and it was brutal enough for you to remember it as always

Oh that's what you meant by intentional. I wasn't sussing him for intentionally biting on the bait, it was that he thought he could easily get away with it, and that's why he bit on the bait. That was reinforced later by him thinking Chimp was suspect, despite the reasoning they gave for jumping on the wagon being very similar.

It was pretty brutal

Considering you only have 26 posts and none of them have stood out to me, should be a sign of what I mean.

26 posts is fine considering it's day one and I play multiple hours behind everyone else? Not standing out to you doesn't really mean shit either, as non-contributive implies I'm not doing stuff, which again, shows that you haven't read my posts?

 

[Doddsy]

Ooo I dont really like Doddsy's posts at all

I'm open to discussion if you want to elaborate on something or is it just the post were I said you looked bad?

 

[Big Man]

eh, he usually doesn't make those posts as scum. town odo always feels like he won't be lynched ever because he's town and knows he can convey his towniness(at least in his head).

there's the amount of his involvement in day 1. most of the stuff he went for this day phase were his own reads and directions. compare this to his last scum game where he sort of just went along with what jeff was doing while 'agreeing' with what he said. he didnt try to overly involved himself in any of those pushes or be aggressive with his reads like he did this game.

also i'm not sure if odo kills the bg day 1 as scum anyways. it would make him look bad the longer he survives opposed to trying to win your favour so youre protecting him and he doesnt look bad for surviving. he wouldn't want to draw the heat of the day kill either and probably would want to use when there's less 'good players' alive to potentially criticize him for his selection.

his general attitude lines up with his town demeanor too.

there's a lot to show odo is town. but most of ALL, he said the day kill in the thread!

hmm the thing about the bodyguard is a good point actually. he'd probably want to keep the bodyguard alive as it would make more sense for him to be alive. regarding the day kill I was just thinking he went a bit hard in justifying his scum read. like he made a post comparing his posts to previous town games and seemed like he had his mind made up. then he went and multiquoted all of his posts and just commented on most of them by saying WEAK. the objective of those weren't to convince anyone since he was daykilling him anyway and it wasn't anything Haza could defend himself from either. I would've thought town Odo would just get his shot off once he was confident and not be worried about having an extensive case to point to afterwards.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Oh that's what you meant by intentional. I wasn't sussing him for intentionally biting on the bait, it was that he thought he could easily get away with it, and that's why he bit on the bait. That was reinforced later by him thinking Chimp was suspect, despite the reasoning they gave for jumping on the wagon being very similar.

It was pretty brutal



26 posts is fine considering it's day one and I play multiple hours behind everyone else? Not standing out to you doesn't really mean shit either, as non-contributive implies I'm not doing stuff, which again, shows that you haven't read my posts?

It's Night 1, son.

 

[RDK]

I'm open to discussion if you want to elaborate on something or is it just the post were I said you looked bad?

I'll take a further look tomorrow when I'm at the office!

Dont like you ignoring the rest of my posts and explanations though and just picking out that one

Easy way for you to throw sus on someone that's already being sussed so it won't stand out as much!

 

[Rugrat]

This Doddsy mallard

 

[Big Man]

me too!

is the only reasoning for this what you said earlier about me zoning on a single player and focusing on them?