Anime Mafia by OMBayBay - Game Thread

[Doddsy]

Chimp was town

Well lethal is scum then right? His role is still a direct counter to Chimp?

 

[Ace]

If you are I suspect Lethal to be our guy given his suggestion to shoot you on top of the other shit, as town, i'm sure you can see how that was an awful suggestion

Yes this is a good point too. Could equally be 3p though.

Of course, we don't even know if there is a 3p - there could be 2 mafia, or even just a single maf left. But I'm currently going to play as if we have 1 and 1 to go.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

With *All* those claims, which one sticks out like a sore fucking thumb?

 

[Ace]

OK so now to completely throw out everything else and play devil's advocate - A black mark against Doddsy is that he's claimed an even night tracker.

We have not seen mafia's even-night killer be revealed yet.

The possibility of him being an even-night mafia killer with some passive secondary (say, like having X-shot lynch immunity) is also there.

 

[RDK]

Going through this Tweet wagon. Seems like if Ace is double voter he was actually the hammer which nobody spotted. Lethal claiming Smark was the hammer though is if it wasn't true and he was trying to get Smark some town points on the Tweet lynch

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Thing that gives me pause with Lethal, yet again, is that's a risky claim to make as if there's no lynchproof characters, you're gonna be found out eventually.

 

[RDK]

OK so now to completely throw out everything else and play devil's advocate - A black mark against Doddsy is that he's claimed an even night tracker.

We have not seen mafia's even-night killer be revealed yet.

The possibility of him being an even-night mafia killer with some passive secondary (say, like having X-shot lynch immunity) is also there.

This was Brad I think

 

[Bobby Barrows]

This was Brad I think

You're right. Brad was the Even Night Killer. I think I had him listed as Odd Night for some reason. D'oh.

 

[Doddsy]

Thing that gives me pause with Lethal, yet again, is that's a risky claim to make as if there's no lynchproof characters, you're gonna be found out eventually.

Who claimed first, him or chimp?

 

[Ace]

These roles still confuse the hell out of me though.

Chimp was "unkillable during day" - yet all we have had was a 1 x shot daykiller. If his role does not include lynch immunity, that's a fucking bizarre role too.

I'm a little nervous of jumping in on Lethal on the basis of his role tbh but I do agree that he looks like the obvious option here.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Who claimed first, him or chimp?

I actually don't know. Let me get back to you.

 

[Ace]

You're right. Brad was the Even Night Killer. I think I had him listed as Odd Night for some reason. D'oh.

Oh fair enough then.

 

[Doddsy]

These roles still confuse the hell out of me though.

Chimp was "unkillable during day" - yet all we have had was a 1 x shot daykiller. If his role does not include lynch immunity, that's a fucking bizarre role too.

I'm a little nervous of jumping in on Lethal on the basis of his role tbh but I do agree that he looks like the obvious option here.

Phenom wasn't specifically a day killer, which leads me to believe lethal is a counter to Chimp still, and he was town.

I'm pretty confident on lethal tbh

 

[Bobby Barrows]

I assure you that nobody is lynchproof

So he says this.

Correct, assuming Tweets was truthful about being beloved. I did ask him to unvote, so I could hammer. If people want me to explain why, I am happy to do so.

Yup, there it is



You're unlynchable aren't you. Cheeky bugger.

And this.

Haha, good try Tweets. I'm the one-punch, if I am the hammer vote I can kill someone who is unlynchable.

Claims first.

Basically I can't die during day but will die if anyone ever visits me at night

Chimp claims a few hours after.

A godfather has not flipped yet. Brad was in charge of the even night kill, but nothing was mentioned about being immune to investigation. The positive cop result is the only reason I am hesitant to push on him.

Anyway, the more I think of it, isn't it just a little convenient that the reason we've sussed KIF (no results) yet Doddsy is skating by with no results either? He tracked Tweets who apparently didn't go anywhere on N2, and same again last night for Ace. He was also being heavily sussed by Odo.

POE list, Jeff? Gimme a moment

But then he says this, despite Brad's flip clearly stating he came back town on the first two investigations.

 

[RDK]

So he says this.



And this.



Claims first.



Chimp claims a few hours after.



But then he says this, despite Brad's flip clearly stating he came back town on the first two investigations.