90's got incredibly weak in the Horror department thanks in part to the major film recession of the era. There was a time when Summer Movies and Horror just weren't selling. As good as Scream was, it's difficult to really say anything else competed against it.
I would not be opposed to starting a horror movie thread to talk about all our favorite but me and you might be the only ones marking over the ones that are old as shit lmao I do love that you included Caligari tho, I had to watch that in this history of cinema class I took and I fuckin loved it