BTB of the Year Awards - 2023 (VOTING)

[Dubble J]

Hello one and all! I hope everyone's 2024 is off to a great start so far. I am hoping to make 2024 a great year for the BTB section and want to kick things off with some awards for 2023! For this first year of awards, I think we'll keep it fairly simple with just a handful of awards because I know it's going to be difficult for people to remember specific things from the year. Going forward, I'm going to pull a page from WolfBeast over at WrestlingClique and will set up an ongoing short-list thread where people can keep ongoing lists of things they want to remember/consider for year end awards.

But, since we didn't do that last year, we're going to need to use our collective brainpower to remember things that happened in 2023 in our own projects and our favorite projects.

So here's a couple things you can do in this thread.

1. Highlight your own work. Yes, that's right. Go ahead and pimp your own stuff. Tell us what you think people should consider for each category from your own project. Toot that horn baby!
   
   
2. Highlight others' work. Tooting your own horn is fun but let's toot the horns of other people! So remind us of what stood out in your favorite projects of 2023.
   
   
3. Finally, DM me a list of three (3) nominees for each category. No, you don't HAVE to do all the categories and you don't HAVE to give me three each.. but it's certainly strongly encouraged to do so to make sure we get a nice list of nominations when we get to the voting stage. You have until January 22nd at 12PM eastern to DM me your nominations.

BTB of the Year
There were a lot of great projects in 2023. Which ones stood out the most? What BTB will be the best of them all? You cannot nominate yourself.

Booker of the Year
Which writer did the best bookings? Wrote the best matches and promos? Who is the 2023 All Star Writer? You cannot nominate yourself.

Non-Wrestling BTB of the Year
The Shady Acres award for best BTB in the Non-Wrestling Section. You cannot nominate yourself.

BTB Show of the Year
Which show within a BTB was the grand daddy of them all for 2023? 1 of your 3 nominations can be your own work.

BTB Match of the Year
What was the best written match within a BTB of 2023? 1 of your 3 nominations can be your own work.

BTB Promo of the Year
What was the best written promo within a BTB of 2023? 1 of your 3 nominations can be your own work.
​

So feel free to reply and toot your horn for each of these categories and also what you want people to consider/go back and read from the various projects of 2023. And then DM me some nominations! Again the deadline is January 22nd at 12PM eastern.

​

 

[Dubble J]

I added a Non Wrestling BTB of the Year category because that was an oversight on my part. I also added some verbiage around what you can or cannot nominate yourself for when you DM me. In the next couple days I will put together a list of the top BTBs of the year according to BTBOTM voting points and also try to highlight some BTB shows, matches, and promos that I can recall from my favorite projects.

 

[Dubble J]

As you think about what to nominate - here are some BTBOTM factoids for you.

Here are the TOP TEN BTBs of 2023 according to BTB of the month voting points.

1. Pandemic Project by DTP (197 points)
2. WCW/ECW Alliance by RDT (182 points)
3. WWE 2019 - No Wildcards by Roy Mustang (169 points)
4. WCW 1995 by Dubb (131 points)
5. WWE 2019 and Beyond - DamageCTRL & Rasky (119 points)
6. WCW by Jim Cornette by Stojy (114 points)
7. WWE: New Vision by Order (101 points)
8. AEW by Deco90 (68 points)
9. TNA by Tig (64 points)
10. WWE: Unleash the Fury by KOP (57 points)

Special shoutout to Pandemic Project (DTP), Alliance (RDT), and No Wildcards (Roy) being the 3 BTBs that were represented in all 12 of 2023's BTB of the Month lists.

Also here are the top performing writers of the year based on number of podiums (1st, 2nd, 3rds) in 2023.

1. DTP with 8 total podium finishes. This includes 1 1st place finish (April 2023) as well as 5 2nd place finishes and 2 3rd place finishes.

2. RDT and Roy with 6 podium finishes. Both RDT (December) and Roy (February) picked up 1 1st place finish. Roy grabbed 4 2nd places and 1 3rd place while RDT had 2 2nd places and 3 3rd place finishes.

3. Stojy with 5 podiums including back to back 1st places (October & November) for Jim Cornette's WCW. Stojy also got 2 2nd places and 1 3rd place. Stojy is also the only writer to podium with two projects, with WWE 2009 getting a 2nd place finish in March.

Besides Stojy - two other writers nabbed 2 1st place finishes in 2023. That being Order and Dubble J.

Rounding out the list of other writers who grabbed the top spot in BTBOTM in 2023 included Deco90 and Tig!

 

[Dubble J]

Promos people should check out:

The Horsewomen are dead - WWE 2019 and Beyond

Brock Lesnar joins Team nWo for War Games - WCW/ECW Alliance

Best in TNA... Best in the World? - TNA by Tig

A Moxley Family Affair - TNA by Tig

Vince McMahon Returns - WWE Unleash the Fury

Hulkamania's Funeral - WCW 1995: Going to War


Shows people should check out:

Queen of the Ring - WWE 2019: No wildcards

Summerslam - WWE 2019: No Wildcards

Fall Brawl - WCW/ECW The Alliance Lives

Anarchy Rulz - WCW/ECW The Alliance Lives

Bash at the Beach - WCW by Jim Cornette

Great American Bash - WCW by Jim Cornette

Clash of the Champions - Pandemic Project

Summerslam - Pandemic Project

Revolution - WWE 2019 and Beyond

No Way Out - WWE Unleash the Fury

Royal Rumble - WWE Unleash the Fury

Armageddon - WWE: The New Vision

World War 3 - WCW 1995: Going to War

Starrcade - WCW 1995: Going to War

Matches people should check out:

Four Horsewomen vs. Sisters of Doom - War Games - WWE Revolution

Brock Lesnar vs. Rob Van Dam - Anarchy Rulz - WCW/ECW The Alliance Lives

War Games - Fall Brawl - WCW/ECW The Alliance Lives

John Morrison vs. Randy Orton - Summerslam - WWE 2009 The WWE Championship Scene

Edge & Christian vs. The Hardyz - Great American Bash - WCW by Jim Cornette

Goldberg vs. Vader - Great American Bash - WCW by Jim Cornette

Johnny Gargano vs. Daniel Bryan - Clash of the Champions - Pandemic Project

Adam Cole vs. Finn Balor Iron Man Match - NXT TakeOver XXX - Pandemic Project

Aleister Black vs. Andrade Cien Almas Iron Man Match - Monday Night Raw June 1 - WWE 2019: No Wild Cards

Hangman Page vs. PAC - AEW Dynamite - AEW: All Elite Wrestling

Royal Rumble Match - Royal Rumble - WWE: Unleash the Fury

Sheamus vs. Evan Bourne - Armageddon - WWE: The New Vision

World War 3 Match - World War 3 - WCW 1995: Going to War

Sting vs. The Great Muta - Starrcade - WCW 1995: Going to War

 

[Dubble J]

I present to you...

THE 2023 BTB OF THE YEAR AWARDS!

The Bookies?

The nominations are in and I thank the five people (BattleTank, DTP, Dubb, RDT, and Roy Mustang) who helped by sending in nominations that got us to this point. I've tabulated the nominations to have the top 5 (or 6 or 7 depending on ties).

Now comes the important part. The VOTING. Anyone can send in votes. The rule here is you cannot vote for anything involving yourself or your own project.

For each category, please choose a winner and a runner up. The runner up totals will only be used in the event of a tie.

You have two weeks to get me your votes. Deadline is February 5th at 8AM eastern. You can DM to me on the forum or on Discord.


BTB Promo of the Year
A Moxley Family Affair - TNA by Tig

Christian and Edge's Contract Signing (8/14/18 Smackdown) - WWE ~ Way It Should've Gone by Finishline

Hulkamania's Funeral - WCW 1995: Going to Way by Dubb

The Horsewomen are dead - WWE 2019 and Beyond by DamageCTRL

W.A.S.T.E debut - WWE: New Vision by Order



BTB Match of the Year
Adam Cole vs Kyle O'Reilly - NXT: End of the Line - Looking Glass's NXT

Booker T, Diamond Dallas Page, The Giant, Hulk Hogan & Kurt Angle vs Triple H, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, Sean O'Haire & Brock Lesnar - Fall Brawl - WCW/ECW: The Alliance Lives by RDT

Four Horsewomen vs. Sisters of Doom - War Games, WWE Revolution - WWE 2019 and Beyond by Damage CTRL

Goldberg vs. Vader, Great American Bash - WCW by Jim Cornette by Stojy

Royal Rumble Match, Royal Rumble - WWE Unleash the Fury by KOP

World War 3 Match, World War 3 - WCW 1995: Going to War by Dubb



BTB Show of the Year
Armageddon 2010 - WWE: The New Vision by Order

Revolution - WWE 2019 and Beyond by Damage CTRL

Summerslam - WWE 2019: No Wildcards by Roy Mustang

Survivor Series Fall Brawl - WWE: The New Vision by Order

World War 3 '95, WCW 1995: Going to War by Dubb



Non-Wrestling BTB of the Year
1979 California Angels by Autumn Wind

Brentford Saga by CakeWalker

Grey Dog Comics Universe by Chris

DC Extended Universe by Shade

NBA: The Modern Game Era by RDT




BTB of the Year
The Pandemic Project by DTP

World Championship Wrestling by Jim Cornette by Stojy

WCW/ECW 2001 and Beyond - The Alliance Lives by RDT

WCW 1995: Going to War by Dubb

WWE 2019: No Wildcards by Roy Mustang

WWE 2019 and Beyond - DamageCTRL & Rasky



Booker of the Year
DamageCTRL

DTP

Dubb

RDT

Roy Mustang

Shade

Stojy




​

 

[Tig]

Awesome stuff here, will make up for no noms by voting.

Would there be a possibility in a BTB log-type deal? Think you had mentioned? Would make it super easy for the time this rolls around next year. Best of luck all.

 

[Dubble J]

Awesome stuff here, will make up for no noms by voting.

Would there be a possibility in a BTB log-type deal? Think you had mentioned? Would make it super easy for the time this rolls around next year. Best of luck all.

Yep, plan to get that up and running after we wrap this up.

 

[Dubble J]

Here's a friendly reminder for people to send in their votes for this! Still got a little less than 5 days left, but wanted to shoot the reminder out especially with BTBOTM voting also about to go live!

VOTE OR DIE (ok it's not that serious, but you should definitely vote!)

 

[Dubble J]

Last call for votes! Would love a couple more! Still plenty to decide and every vote counts!