Best SummerSlam Tournament Round 1A: 2005 (5) vs 2006 (28)

[Chris]

VS

​

 

[Apoho Creed]

This was a tough vote for me to be honest. I love Flair vs Foley, Batista vs Cena, DX vs The Mchamons with Edge getting the win over Cena put it on the top even though Summerslam 2005 had damn good matches as well. What hurts SS 2005 for me is Hogan vs HBK. Knowing the backstory going into the feud and Shawn having to work his ass off not only in the Ring during the Match, but putting effort into the feud it sours me so hard fucking Hogan getting put over vs HBK.

 

[Chris]

Not a hard vote for me at all tbh lol 05 doesn't have anything that stands out like crazy but it's solid through and through and a very well built card. I love Edge/Cena from 06 and thought McMahons/DX and Flair/Foley were good too but the rest of the card was decent at best and at worst. Also just a general disdain for 06 WWE and the angles that lead up to 06 hurt it for me as well.

 

[Deezy]

Overselling unprofessional Shawn Michaels having his hissy fit in the ring gets it

 

[Keith]

Yeah 2006 is a bit patchy. Its probably lifted by the main event. Hated the second coming of DX. 2005 is solid overall and doesn't have the same low lights.