In Your House.
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x5atq_wwf-hbk-shawn-michaels-vs-ken-shamr_news?search_algo=2#.UUUWvxwUi0k
The match if you're interested.
I agree the roster was stacked at the time, the KOTR win is odd as you say as it didn't leave anywhere, it's an odd one but WWF is full of...