Search results

  • Welcome to "The New" Wrestling Smarks Forum!

    I see that you are not currently registered on our forum. It only takes a second, and you can even login with your Facebook! If you would like to register now, pease click here: Register

    Once registered please introduce yourself in our introduction thread which can be found here: Introduction Board


  1. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    ^ ditto n always a good thing to be honest in your grading. I always try to add some text if there's some tightness n usually will offer a few booking solution to consider. It's good to be flexible sometimes
  2. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    Yeah I 100% support clarity here and yeah while its been good times lately I can understand smark just wants ppl to know how we grade and for all of us who do grade to all be on the same page :)
  3. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    I think regardless though we agree that more promos should not mean automatic extra points going fwd
  4. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    ^ this is how I grade atm unofficially though
  5. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    As i said above that's great then. I just wanted to make sure we were on the same page. And I agree w u that if a promo stands head and shoulders above then it shouldn't be too punished by a lazy partner anyways.
  6. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    Then I think we're golden
  7. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    ^ just to clarify What happens if team a n b have 2 players each. All do a promo. Promo a is best but promo b stink. Promo c and d are very good , better than b, but not a. Ab and cd r on teams. Who wins?
  8. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    Yeah the tag rules needed tweaking regardless because we have teams of one and teams of 2 users n that obviously needs to be balanced and I agree that it should be best promo wins if there's an imbalance in players. Only time I'd consider more is if we have 4 players in a 2 v 2 n one team has...
  9. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    ^ which isn't a problem going forward btw! Just as long as this implemented fir future shows as obviously wouldn't be super Fajr doing that after the promo deadline
  10. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    Like for example I'd have tacked on my 2nd promo to my first under this system as its two scenes in the same chapter, if that makes sense, as opposed to two stories
  11. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    Yeah i get that too and like I said sometimes i do find it more effective to split a long promo in 2 parts. In this case I'd be better off writing a long one so it all counts , which really is nbd any ways. I do see the value in fairness here as well.
  12. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    I do like the idea of 2 promo at times but I really don't want ppl to be dissuaded by that so if ppl just want to commit to.1 per that's cool w me . Mb can do max 2 on championship bout or smth
  13. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    That way no one gets an "advantage " for writing novels or multis n everyone is equal (imo)
  14. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    So why not just make 2 rules : 1 - 1 promo per match, period 2 length doesn't give you bonus points after x words
  15. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    ^ just curious btw !
  16. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    I guess the question is has some matches actually been affected by this or is this a precaution as well? Because I haven't really seen anyone auto win from content spamming to this point ?
  17. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    Basically my opinion is 2 promos don't auto win but I do think grade wise if two promos posted flow together better than one singular good promo then ya in that case I do think effort should be factored in to a degree
  18. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    I still think it's not too difficult to balance if u like the sum of two promos over 1 though, like I personally like to write scenes that follow each other but not in one giant post, so I imo its really simple. You just count everyone's posted promo as 1 grade anyways. I'm probably not gonna...
  19. Canadian Dragon

    AMA New Grading System: Best Promo Wins

    I've no problem with switching over to best promo as that's generally how I've been grading anyways . I've never been one to think one should win for posting more anyways. I generally judge by overall content so if there is more to read that is more content to judge and that cuts both ways...
Top Bottom