Here is who I would nominate, Nominees are in black, With the winners in red:
Superstar of the Year
The Undertaker
Triple H
Edge
Shawn Michaels
Chris Jericho
Match of the Year
Taker/Edge WrestleMania
Michaels/Flair WrestleMania
Jericho/Michaels Judgment Day
Cena/Batista...