TWO Year End Awards

[Kaedon]

Lou Thesz/Ric Flair Award (Wrestler of the Year)
Chris Jericho

Most Valuable MMA Fighter
Brock Lesnar

Most Outstanding Wrestler
Bryan Danielson

Biggest Box Office Draw
Brock Lesnar

Feud Of The Year
Chris Jericho vs. Shawn Michaels

Tag Team Of The Year
John Morrison and The Miz

Most Improved
The Miz

Best On Interviews
Chris Jericho

Most Charismatic
John Cena

Best Technical Wrestler
Bryan Danielson

Bruiser Brody Award
Necro Butcher

Best High Flying Wrestler
Evan Bourne

Most Over-rated
Vladimir Kozlov

Most Under-rated
MVP

Promotion Of The Year
Ultimate Fighting Championship

Best Weekly Television Show
Ultimate Fighting Championship: The Ultimate Fighter

Most Outstanding Fighter
Georges St. Pierre

Match Of The Year
Chris Jericho vs. Shawn Michaels (Ladder match, No Mercy, Portland, Oregon, October 5)

Fight Of The Year
Quinton Jackson vs. Forrest Griffin (Las Vegas, NV, July 5)

Rookie Of The Year
KAI

Best Non Wrestler
Larry Sweeney

Best Television Announcer
Matt Striker

Worst TV Announcer
Mike Adamle

Best Major Show
WM 24

Worst Major Show
Survivor Series 2008

Best Wrestling Maneuver
Even Borune's Shooting Star Press

Most Disgusting Promotional Tactic
Jeff Hardy Stairwell Attack

Worst TV Show
TNA Impact

Worst Match Of The Year
Triple H vs. Vladimir Kozlov vs. Edge (Survivor Series, Boston, MA, November 23)

Worst Feud Of The Year
Kane vs. Rey Mysterio

Worst Promotion Of The Year
TNA

Best Booker Of The Year
Joe Silva

Promoter Of The Year
Dana White

Best Gimmick
Santino Marella

Worst Gimmick
The Great Khali (Punjabi Playboy)

Best Pro Wrestling Book
Gorgeous George: The Gender-Bending Wrestler Who Created American Pop Culture - John Capouya

Best Wrestling DVD
Ric Flair - The Definitive Collection​

Wow, Meltzer removed his mouth from the small cock of Japanese wrestling to the throbbing man love of Dana White. I disagree with pretty much all of them. Who's with me?

 

[LadyHotrod]

I agree with The Miz being most improved. He used to be an annoying dickhead but I've really come to like him a lot. I think him and Morrison are fucking hilarious.

 

[xtremebadass]

I agree with this entire list.

Worst TV Announcer
Mike Adamle

However, this disturbed me deeply.

 

[seX-Power]

For overrated and underrated is he talking about like overused and underused? Or as in over/under rated by the WWE.

I disagree with a lot as well, especially the 'Worst' categories.

 

[MikeRaw]

I actually agree with alot. A few he needs to be clear on though. When he does Overrated/Underrated, does he mean by the wwe, or by the fans? People should be specific on that.
However, I agree with most. Especially feud of the year.

 

[Kaedon]

I think its Blue how he thinks MMA and WWE are nearly the same thing. A wrestling booker does a hell of a lot of different things than an MMA booker. Its just really dumb imo. Unless....MMA is all a work :shifty:

 

[Axis]

Most over-rated as Koslov and MOTY as Jericho vs HBK are jokes. Meltzer doesn't like Koslov because Meltzer tends to be a fucktard. And the Y2J/HBK ladder match wasn't even their best of the year; besides that anyway, Flair/Michaels was EASILY the best match of the year. Meltzer is all about MOOVEZ~ and usually ignores emotion and real psychology.

 

[Travis40]

Worst TV Show
TNA Impact

Worst Promotion Of The Year
TNA

​

Sounds about right

 

[NinoBrown]

Most Disgusting Promotional Tactic
Jeff Hardy Stairwell Attack

Damn right!

 

[Kaedon]

People are mad about that because it WORKED. Why was it disgusting? Because they played off something that was....REAL!?

FTR: Meltzer gave HBK/Flair ***1/2

He's out of his fucking mind.

 

[Seventh Reason]

Agree with Kozlov as over-rated but MVP under-rated? Is this clouded judgement because of the kayfabe losing streak? My vote goes to Primo.

 

[Soulpower]

I hate, hate, hate, hate the fact that they put in MMA along with wrestling. They should keep them separate.

 

[Moonlight Drive]

SP is right, seperate awards for MMA and wrestling.

On topic, Meltzer's ratings and awards are usual bullshit anyway. These ones are spot on except for a few, namely MOTY (Flair vs HBK or Edge vs Taker are on a whole other level to any matches) and over/underrated.

 

[Chuck Taylor's Grenade]

how can Evan Bourne's shooting star press be the best wrestling manuever of the year? What about the cop killah, the standing corkscrew 450, anything by PAC? And was Vladimir vs. Edge vs. Triple H really the worst match of the year? Personally I think AJ Styles vs. Frank Trigg was the worst match of the year maybe the worst match ever.

 

[LKP]

Aj styles vs frank trigg was the worst match of the year. Or kane vs show vs henry. Mind you i agree with all those awards though.