WS Christmas Mafia 2022

[Poyser]

LMAO literally no matter what way I come into a game I'm sus day 1 by somebody.


But what I see so far is... Not much of anything. 4 of us started the game 2 being noobs Tommy brought up food we all rolled with it waiting for others to jump in. I announced I'd be out for work.

Ekko jumps on tries to move the game out of food talk that Tommy started. Takes a stab at grim for his combative but lax reaction to food talk. Why didn't grim try to get us moving on from Food? Juice goes for ekko, ekko goes for juice. Tpein comes in with the insta desire to land a lynch (pretty par for him every game I've played so far (but every time it reads odd to me lol) and we're pretty much where we are now. As others join in they respond to the food talk. Wangman doing the thing of popping in contributing nothing and ghosting a bit.

My biggest takeaway is that someone needs to start a christmas food thread outside of mafia it'd apparently be a banger.

This is mostly just commentary tbf. Is there anybody you think looks shady so far? Or anybody you think is probably town?

 

[Chris]

I also think flood the thread Ekko will come regardless of alignment when he has more posts to reply to one by one on a readback lmao

 

[Poyser]

I agree the not reading the role post was a lie, it's just what I see as "chaotic Ekko" lol it's more semantics anyway bc I think the more sus part is how he abandoned Grim tho

And yeah he hasn't explained the Juice vote at all I'm pretty sure.

Tweet has only come on to vote Barry with no explanation too I think? I don't think he'd do that just bc Ekko of all people were asking people to

yeah tweet post was sus, forgot about that

 

[Poyser]

I also think flood the thread Ekko will come regardless of alignment when he has more posts to reply to one by one on a readback lmao

that's possible too, but im sure someone (jeff?) said last game that he's not as bad with it when he's scum. i dont think ive actually seen ekko as scum yet but i could be wrong on that. i dont remember it either way

 

[Poyser]

well i think i saw him roll scum and not show up maybe

 

[Chris]

Oh it looks like Tweet voted after Ekko already switched to Juice actually

 

[Poyser]

yeah problem with tweet is he has just been incredibly apathetic in general lately, its a bit hard to gauge until he starts posting more

 

[Lethal]

lol breh
if you're gonna be gone for 8+ hours could ya give us any early leanings you got and perhaps cast a vote?

Since you asked so nicely (and my phone pinged)

Ekko not nearly as aggressive as normal, but could be a change of tact after how heated the last game got. He did even say the thread was dead, so, eh. I'm not a fan of him just picking Barry and Juice at random and then voting both, only seemingly switching to Juice cos she voted him.

I think Tommy sounds natural and relaxed, even if spurred on by the food discussion.

Barry did look a little panicked with the ekko vote and his over-explanation of guessing Ekko's motive seemed stretchy.

Tweet dropping in with a vote sticks out.

Vote: Tweet

Sorry kweh

 

[Lethal]

Johnny boy needs to know everyone gets sussed. His reaction seems frustrated and not worried scum so that's good for him in that context for now.

 

[John McHenry]

This is mostly just commentary tbf. Is there anybody you think looks shady so far? Or anybody you think is probably town?

I agree that Tommy is likely town. I feel he came in like me excited to start playing but not really knowing how to start looked at the theme and started a convo.

The grim coming in combative read odd to me but I don't think I've played a game with Grim if I did he wasn't active so I'm not sure his style so I see that as odd.

Your point on Ekko, he does typically post a lot more, but everyones been complaining about it so that could be a factor? As for him being chaotic that's usually day 3 from what I've noticed.

I think you and I don't get each others styles (or that you read my naivete as sus a lot) But I think you're being genuine even if you do have your eye on me.

Never played with Chris so no clue.

Smark don't really have a read.

Pein being pein so far I mean that's how he's come into ever game for me.

We'll see when Wang and Dean pop back in as both games I've played with them they seem to be silent for long stretches of time. Wang did that last game and it certainly bit me.

 

[Chris]

I'm not sure what to make of Smark yet myself tbh him dismissing any option of voting Juice day 1 I really didn't like, but at the same time, scum smark would never do that right? Like regardless of Juice's alignment, I don't think he'd say that about a partner nor would he be against a townie lynch that might be easier to sit back and watch. Maybe a higher chance he does if if they aren't aligned to try and have "I told you so" town points if she flips but idk I don't really see it

 

[John McHenry]

I'm not sure what to make of Smark yet myself tbh him dismissing any option of voting Juice day 1 I really didn't like, but at the same time, scum smark would never do that right? Like regardless of Juice's alignment, I don't think he'd say that about a partner nor would he be against a townie lynch that might be easier to sit back and watch. Maybe a higher chance he does if if they aren't aligned to try and have "I told you so" town points if she flips but idk I don't really see it

I mean honestly that seems more site owner trying to make it fair for juice to me and less game?

 

[Chris]

I mean honestly that seems more site owner trying to make it fair for juice to me and less game?

So you'd just read it as null rn?

 

[Chris]

Oh i guess so that's what your list essentially says lol

I kinda see that too, I think scum smark really likes winning a little too tho FWIW and that means he'd be less likely to do something like that as an owner

 

[Poyser]

I'm not sure what to make of Smark yet myself tbh him dismissing any option of voting Juice day 1 I really didn't like, but at the same time, scum smark would never do that right? Like regardless of Juice's alignment, I don't think he'd say that about a partner nor would he be against a townie lynch that might be easier to sit back and watch. Maybe a higher chance he does if if they aren't aligned to try and have "I told you so" town points if she flips but idk I don't really see it

I could def see him do it as S/T but yeah you're right, no way they're S/S

My problem with it was more him giving himself a reason to not read her entirely