WCW's GOAT Round 1: Eddie Guerrero vs. Kevin Nash vs. Elix Skipper vs. Dean Malenko

[Hoss]

11. Eddie Guerrero vs. Kevin Nash vs. Elix Skipper vs. Dean Malenko

Who woulda thought… the leader of the Wolfpac comes toe to toe with three vanilla midgets in the first round! Unfortunately for Nash he meets 3 of the top cruiserweights not only in WCW, but EVER! Malenko is credited as one of WCW’s greatest Cruiserweight champions, while Eddie G also flaunts a star studded career in WCW’s midcard ranks, while Skipper boasts one of the greatest repertoires of any superstar ever! Can Nash’s success at the highest level compare to the in-ring abilities of his opponents?

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

Re: WCW's GOAT Round 1: Eddie Guerrero vs. Kevin Nash vs. Elix Skipper vs. Dean Malenk

Nash takes this one by a nose.

 

[Fuji Vice]

Re: WCW's GOAT Round 1: Eddie Guerrero vs. Kevin Nash vs. Elix Skipper vs. Dean Malenk

Skipper's good and all, and I actually really like the guy, but he's the first one chopped here. Next up would be Eddie Guerrero, who I have always loved but also realize had way more success in WWE than in WCW (from a booking and match quality standpoint). Dean Malenko is an easy candidate for GOAT from all wrestling promotions, one only need look at some of his Japanese work to see that. However, as with Scott Hall before him, I must give my vote to Kevin Nash here simply for the fact that without him, there would be no WCW the way we know it. Plus the dude threw Rey Mysterio into a trailer like a lawn dart!

Kevin Nash

 

[Cyrus Riddle]

Re: WCW's GOAT Round 1: Eddie Guerrero vs. Kevin Nash vs. Elix Skipper vs. Dean Malenk

Have to give this one to Nash

 

[Postman Dave]

Re: WCW's GOAT Round 1: Eddie Guerrero vs. Kevin Nash vs. Elix Skipper vs. Dean Malenk

Skipper? He's a footnote in TNA history, let alone WCW!

Nash wins, but just barely over Malenko.

 

[Kushikimi]

Re: WCW's GOAT Round 1: Eddie Guerrero vs. Kevin Nash vs. Elix Skipper vs. Dean Malenk

Kevin Nash for the same reason that I voted Scott Hall, he was catalyst in one of the most known stables in the history of wrestling and a catalyst in the Monday Night Wars. Thought Malenko gets an honorable mention here.

 

[Gentleman Jake]

Re: WCW's GOAT Round 1: Eddie Guerrero vs. Kevin Nash vs. Elix Skipper vs. Dean Malenk

it's Nash and the lawndart thing was epic but I am voting for him cuz he was Vinny Vegas

 

[Hoss]

Re: WCW's GOAT Round 1: Eddie Guerrero vs. Kevin Nash vs. Elix Skipper vs. Dean Malenk

I'm voting for Nash for being Ozz.