2026 WS Fantasy Baseball Keeper League Discussion Thread

  • Welcome to "The New" Wrestling Smarks Forum!

    I see that you are not currently registered on our forum. It only takes a second, and you can even login with your Facebook! If you would like to register now, pease click here: Register

    Once registered please introduce yourself in our introduction thread which can be found here: Introduction Board


Doom

Sports Moderator
Joined
Nov 30, 2012
Messages
61,022
Reaction score
27,429
Points
238
Age
40
Location
Alabama
Favorite Wrestler
oAYiXZo
Favorite Wrestler
8XDaHk1
Favorite Wrestler
eIHNFff
Favorite Wrestler
nock3cf
Favorite Wrestler
SethRollins1
Favorite Wrestler
eAVr0ua
Favorite Sports Team
ZHIAHN6
Favorite Sports Team
WrE8t1L
Favorite Sports Team
cJttyo5
Favorite Sports Team
Brad6
Since Brett drafted him first, I suggest Rosie to make another choice.
 

Rosie

Neo Genesis
Joined
Apr 16, 2016
Messages
45,725
Reaction score
21,186
Points
128
Location
New Brunswick, Canada
Favorite Wrestler
9yQJpez
Favorite Wrestler
edge
Favorite Wrestler
dJvrW4y
Favorite Wrestler
kevinsteen
Favorite Wrestler
q9gbHdQ
Favorite Wrestler
Se3BZPQ
Favorite Sports Team
2DciFqq
Favorite Sports Team
OQcgyMS
Favorite Sports Team
coloradoavalanche
Favorite Sports Team
vCLYUUD
Brad Keller RP then
 
  • Like
Reactions: Doom

Doom

Sports Moderator
Joined
Nov 30, 2012
Messages
61,022
Reaction score
27,429
Points
238
Age
40
Location
Alabama
Favorite Wrestler
oAYiXZo
Favorite Wrestler
8XDaHk1
Favorite Wrestler
eIHNFff
Favorite Wrestler
nock3cf
Favorite Wrestler
SethRollins1
Favorite Wrestler
eAVr0ua
Favorite Sports Team
ZHIAHN6
Favorite Sports Team
WrE8t1L
Favorite Sports Team
cJttyo5
Favorite Sports Team
Brad6
I'm gonna add the players that was drafted by y'all tomorrow on the WS Fantasy Baseball page, so everyone will have their players.
 

Cereal Killer

Active Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2025
Messages
181
Reaction score
141
Points
43
Age
51
Gotta get a replacement for Profar...great. You had one job.
 

Jam

Active Member
Joined
Sep 14, 2022
Messages
161
Reaction score
189
Points
43
Age
32
Hey guys, I mentioned this on the Discord about this discussion I had with multiple AI where it analyzes our teams. It'll give us a brief overview of our teams and will even predict a winner and rank where each of our teams will place this season.

Remember this is meant to be taken with a grain of salt. Let's take a look.

NOTE: The bolded text are what the AI want to highlight as something to look at to improve your team.

----------------------------------

In 10th place - Team Necro

Necro’s veteran build gives this team a very stable floor but also limits its upside ceiling relative to the rest of the league. In a points system, players who accumulate counting stats — homers, runs, strikeouts, wins — at elite rates are rewarded heavily. Necro has consistency and experience, and can absolutely outperform a weak team, but this roster does not contain enough high-magnifier scoring contributors to put up the top cumulative point totals. Add in the spring context where players with past injury histories tend to be managed carefully early in the season, and Necro’s ceiling feels capped. The team should still be competitive, but within the context of this league’s scoring environment, it’s the most likely to land in the last position.

In 9th place - Team Matrix

Matrix is a bit of a wildcard. The roster has upside and potential breakouts, especially on the pitching side if arms can exceed expectations. However, this is also a team that carries more prospect and volatility risk, meaning that if a couple of key youngsters fail to deliver or if injuries hit, weekly scoring could slide quickly. Points formats don’t reward partial contributions as much as raw output, so a pitcher who throws fewer innings but strikes out a lot doesn’t necessarily outscore one with volume and moderate strikeout totals. That risk profile pushes Matrix further down the rankings. If some of the young bats and pitchers break out big, this team absolutely climbs, but the most realistic finish based on the health environment and roster construction is toward the bottom half.

In 8th place - Team Hoho

Hoho’s team profile is competitive but lacks the elite accelerator that separates teams above it. There is power, and a deep lineup can generate good weekly scoring totals, but in a points setting, you need either ongoing elite strikeout production from arms — which lifts weekly totals fast — or a handful of MVP-caliber offensive seasons. Hoho has some strong bats and squad depth, but not enough pitching spike ability in early March projections compared to teams landing in the top half. With the latest news that teams are dealing with a lot of mild spring injuries and loading innings carefully, Hoho’s strategy feels like it will produce solid scoring but not consistently top-tier point totals week after week.

In 7th place - Team Tommy

Tommy is a unique roster because it leans into athleticism and speed that isn’t always rewarded at full value in standard points formats unless steals get significant weight. The offense has undeniable upside and can produce across the board, but compared to teams that pile up home runs and strikeouts, Tommy’s scoring is likely steadier and less explosive. That steadiness isn’t inherently bad — it just doesn’t create the weekly scoring spikes rival teams can generate with homer weeks or elite strikeout totals from pitchers. Considering early season pitchers’ health flags and the normal spring attrition in youth arms, Tommy’s path to 1st place is long and requires its bats to outperform expectations while getting above-average innings from starters who historically have some question marks.

In 6th place - Team Cereal Killer

Cereal Killer is a very solid, balanced team, which in a points system translates to consistent weekly scoring potential. The lineup has good run and extra-base production, and with players like Turner and Tucker, this team should never be held down in total offensive point production. The pitching staff includes quality arms who, if they can stay healthy, are capable of sustaining innings and accumulating wins and strikeouts. However — and this is important — the early spring training injury chatter around pitchers and questionable returns on Opening Day means this roster might lack the spike potential others have. In points leagues, balance beats major weaknesses, but to finish top 4 typically requires one of the elite scorers or strikeout juggernauts, which this team doesn’t quite have.

In 5th place - Team Rosie

Rosie sits comfortably in the middle of the top tier. This roster is constructed with power bats and depth in starting pitching that should consistently accumulate innings and strikeouts, which matter a ton in points leagues. With bats like Tucker and other middle-order power contributors, the offense can contribute plenty of scoring. The pitching staff includes high-upside arms — remember that Razor’s lineup actually projects well in cumulative strikeouts and wins — but there are some spring durability questions across multiple rosters this preseason, and Rosie’s staff is not immune to that climate. If a couple of starters break out or stay healthy all year, Rosie could finish even higher. As of now, though, the projection is solid, just slightly behind the elite offense-plus-pitching combinations above.

In 4th place - Team Jam

Jam projects as a very strong offensive heavy hitter with a top-tier power core. The presence of guys like Judge, Tatis, Lindor, and Machado means this team can easily outscore others in runs, home runs, and RBI — the backbone of fantasy points scoring. Judge’s combination of power, walks, and run production makes him one of the most valuable point accumulators in any lineup, and pairing him with other high-impact bats gives Jam a weekly ceiling that is legitimately among the highest in your league. The main reason Jam isn’t higher than third is the rotation’s lack of a true ace who is both healthy and elite in strikeouts, combined with early spring concerns about pitchers’ availability and the fact that bullpen Dodgers-type injuries are trending in the league. Still, Jam’s offense alone should frequently generate enough points to make this team a contender.

In 3rd place - Team R-Troop

R-Troop stays in the top three because of its amen corner strength in elite pitching strikeouts and power hitting, which are exactly the categories that spike weekly scoring in a points format. With strikeout machines like Strider and Cole in the rotation, this team can generate massive pitching point totals almost any given week. Offensively, having multiple power bats capable of 30+ homers contributes big chunks of points. The primary risk that prevents this team from finishing higher is injury volatility, which is significant among frontline arms early in spring discussions league-wide, and the fact that home run power doesn’t always translate to consistent point production if contact rates dip. Over a full season, though, the explosiveness of this roster’s scoring ability keeps them firmly in championship contention.

In 2nd place - Team Brett

Brett maintains a very high projected finish but slips slightly behind Wolverine because of current injury and durability concerns, especially with pitchers who have had trouble staying on the mound in past seasons. This roster’s ceiling remains the single highest in your league thanks to the presence of Ohtani, who in a points format is almost unfair — contributing home runs, runs, RBI AND strikeouts and wins as a starter. Add Freeman and Carroll on the offensive side and deGrom plus Rodón in the rotation and you have a squad that can outscore any team in a single week. However, early season volatility in pitchers returning from injury histories — especially arms like deGrom and Rodón — slightly dampens the weekly consistency projection. If they stay healthy, Brett is easily a #1 candidate. If either misses time, the team still scores well but doesn’t consistently outpace Wolverine’s steady scoring output.

... and the winner according to multiple AI - Team Wolverine

Wolverine remains the most realistic points-league champion because it combines elite everyday offensive production with a pitching staff that should pitch enough innings and provide reliable strikeouts and wins without leaning too heavily on notoriously injury-prone arms. With stars like Soto, Ramírez, Olson, Seager, Albies, and Suzuki anchoring the lineup, this team is built for consistency as well as volume. In a points league where counting stats and extra-base hits are king, Soto’s high walk and OBP rates translate directly to weekly scoring, while Ramírez and Olson provide slugging and runs. The pitching staff is sturdy enough that even if one arm suffers a spring setback, Wolverines won’t drop off sharply. Compared to some other teams that rely on breakouts or ace durability, Wolverine has the safest foundation in both offense and innings — which is exactly what wins total points over 162 games.

Final Big Picture Summary​

If the season started today and played out normally:

Most Likely Champion: Wolverine
Highest Ceiling: Brett
Most Dangerous if Healthy: R-Troop
Best Offensive Core: Jam
Most Balanced Middle Threat: Rosie
Most Likely Surprise Team: Matrix

The league is actually very competitive at the top. The difference between 1st and 4th likely comes down to pitcher health and innings volume.

In a points league, championships usually go to the team that:
  1. Avoids catastrophic pitching injuries
  2. Gets 150+ innings from multiple starters
  3. Has 2–3 hitters who produce elite total bases and OBP
Right now, Wolverine checks the most boxes. Brett has the nuclear button. R-Troop has the strikeout artillery.

And over 162 games, that’s what will decide it.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Matrix and Doom

Doom

Sports Moderator
Joined
Nov 30, 2012
Messages
61,022
Reaction score
27,429
Points
238
Age
40
Location
Alabama
Favorite Wrestler
oAYiXZo
Favorite Wrestler
8XDaHk1
Favorite Wrestler
eIHNFff
Favorite Wrestler
nock3cf
Favorite Wrestler
SethRollins1
Favorite Wrestler
eAVr0ua
Favorite Sports Team
ZHIAHN6
Favorite Sports Team
WrE8t1L
Favorite Sports Team
cJttyo5
Favorite Sports Team
Brad6
I want to know what y'all think of the offline draft and it being a keeper league? Should we do it again? Should we make changes to make it better? Or, go back to normal draft, but keep three players for the next three seasons? I've made it three seasons because I would like to mix it up after it's all up and the first keepers go back to the draft pool.
 
Last edited:

Kairi HoHo

Fallen Angel
Joined
May 14, 2013
Messages
39,957
Reaction score
23,165
Points
138
Age
38
Location
Derry, Maine
Favorite Wrestler
OZO8olA
Favorite Wrestler
Y2tTaaf
Favorite Wrestler
q9gbHdQ
Favorite Wrestler
zPa7dqi
Favorite Wrestler
oLvrzSU
Favorite Wrestler
m4aw1gh
Favorite Sports Team
hPPsgSL
Favorite Sports Team
hlbgCD9
Favorite Sports Team
guuKKYL
Favorite Sports Team
Um6oxIS
I want to know what y'all think of the offline draft and it being a keeper league? Should we do it again? Should we make changes to make it better? Or, go back to normal draft, but keep three players for the next three seasons? I've made it three seasons because I would like to mix it up after it's all up and the first keepers go back to the draft pool.
I liked the Offline Draft. I probably had more fun with it and loved the change up compared to a Draft on ESPN that day it goes by pretty quickly.

Their was alot of strategy with me. I was thinking well if I don't pick up this guy now will I be able to wait a whole Round to get him or not. I love having to think like that thinking making multiple moves ahead which is why I love Chess. I think I said it before the Keepers one Pitcher, RP, and one Batter should be fine I feel but that is just me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Doom

R-Troop

See you after WrestleMania
Joined
Oct 15, 2022
Messages
37,728
Reaction score
18,435
Points
138
Age
41
Location
Long Island
Favorite Wrestler
zackryder
Favorite Wrestler
romanreigns
Favorite Wrestler
samizayn
Favorite Wrestler
7rtdSS0
Favorite Wrestler
LmZfvje
Favorite Wrestler
88j8DYn
Favorite Sports Team
RRzOmtg
Favorite Sports Team
bMIeUcR
Favorite Sports Team
T5Zw0Si
I want to know what y'all think of the offline draft and it being a keeper league? Should we do it again? Should we make changes to make it better? Or, go back to normal draft, but keep three players for the next three seasons? I've made it three seasons because I would like to mix it up after it's all up and the first keepers go back to the draft pool.
Offline drafts are so much easier.

We don't all have to get together online, the shower pace means you can actually research and make an informed decision.

Probably easier if the fantasy site allows offline draft in-client instead of just doing it here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Doom

Cereal Killer

Active Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2025
Messages
181
Reaction score
141
Points
43
Age
51
Offline draft was fine and fun, just too long. Keeper league will be a good time, because who do you keep, the youngsters with potential or the proven guys that you hope keep producing? It'll be fun.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Doom

Cereal Killer

Active Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2025
Messages
181
Reaction score
141
Points
43
Age
51
Can I drop Profar now and pick his replacement or do I have to wait? Thanks
 

Doom

Sports Moderator
Joined
Nov 30, 2012
Messages
61,022
Reaction score
27,429
Points
238
Age
40
Location
Alabama
Favorite Wrestler
oAYiXZo
Favorite Wrestler
8XDaHk1
Favorite Wrestler
eIHNFff
Favorite Wrestler
nock3cf
Favorite Wrestler
SethRollins1
Favorite Wrestler
eAVr0ua
Favorite Sports Team
ZHIAHN6
Favorite Sports Team
WrE8t1L
Favorite Sports Team
cJttyo5
Favorite Sports Team
Brad6
Can I drop Profar now and pick his replacement or do I have to wait? Thanks
You'll have to wait until all the rosters are up before dropping him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cereal Killer

Necro

Hi, I'm Chucky. Wanna play?
Joined
Mar 4, 2020
Messages
28,043
Reaction score
9,719
Points
133
Age
42
Location
Boston, MA
Favorite Wrestler
owenhart
Favorite Wrestler
ricflair
Favorite Wrestler
rickrude
Favorite Wrestler
kotaibushi
Favorite Wrestler
ajstyles
Favorite Wrestler
scottsteiner
Favorite Sports Team
LechI0u
Favorite Sports Team
fRXTMaD
Favorite Sports Team
RHZ7KJg
Favorite Sports Team
WYT3shw
Prefer online draft, this was very difficult to keep up with in this style for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Doom

Tommy Bedlam

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2022
Messages
3,750
Reaction score
2,650
Points
113
Age
38
I was against the offline draft initially, but wound up really enjoying it. Love the keeper aspect. Would be happy to see it run for longer than 3 seasons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Doom

Necro

Hi, I'm Chucky. Wanna play?
Joined
Mar 4, 2020
Messages
28,043
Reaction score
9,719
Points
133
Age
42
Location
Boston, MA
Favorite Wrestler
owenhart
Favorite Wrestler
ricflair
Favorite Wrestler
rickrude
Favorite Wrestler
kotaibushi
Favorite Wrestler
ajstyles
Favorite Wrestler
scottsteiner
Favorite Sports Team
LechI0u
Favorite Sports Team
fRXTMaD
Favorite Sports Team
RHZ7KJg
Favorite Sports Team
WYT3shw
Yeah, I think the timing was tough with work for me. Maybe I’d prefer to have one set 3-4 hour period similar to nfl drafts.
 

Doom

Sports Moderator
Joined
Nov 30, 2012
Messages
61,022
Reaction score
27,429
Points
238
Age
40
Location
Alabama
Favorite Wrestler
oAYiXZo
Favorite Wrestler
8XDaHk1
Favorite Wrestler
eIHNFff
Favorite Wrestler
nock3cf
Favorite Wrestler
SethRollins1
Favorite Wrestler
eAVr0ua
Favorite Sports Team
ZHIAHN6
Favorite Sports Team
WrE8t1L
Favorite Sports Team
cJttyo5
Favorite Sports Team
Brad6
Two people drafted Chase Burns: Necro drafted him in the 12th Round and Tommy drafted him in the 14th Round.

You must make a different pick @Tommy Bedlam. Sorry buddy.

Once he picks his player, everyone should have all their players on the roster.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tommy Bedlam