All that rushing led me to be wrong on Jeff :( Sorry dude, you were even going to be my vote today.
From Odo's "for reference" post
Odo: Phenom, Alco/Magic, Jeff
Magic: Odo, ???, ???
Barry: Phenom, Mitch, Jeff
Phenom: Odo, Chris, ???
Chris: Phenom, Magic, Jeff
Mitch: Phenom, Magic, Chris...