WCW's GOAT Round 1: Cactus Jack vs. Sid vs. Scott Steiner vs. Konnan

[Hoss]

9. Cactus Jack vs. Sid vs. Scott Steiner vs. Konnan

How well will two of the most infamous meatheads in all of wrestling (Sid and Steiner) fare against one hardcore icon and one Latino icon? It all comes down to a respect factor, something that could benefit either of them. All these men have had their epic moments throughout WCW, some more than others, but at the end of it all, only one shall advance!

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

Scott Steiner reinvented himself in WCW and also had some classic matches. I have to vote for Big Poppa Pump.

 

[Fuji Vice]

Konnan even being in this thing is laughable, he's a horrible wrestler and his mic work is incredibly repetetive. I always liked Sid, but I can count on one hand the matches he had that I'd consider excellent, and still have fingers left. Scott Steiner was half of an amazing tag team before becoming the genetic freak, big bad booty daddy that we all know and love today. However, his bizarre yet captivating promos aside, once he roided up, he didn't perform as well in the ring. On the other hand, Cactus Jack destroyed himself night in and night out and has at least three ****+ matches to his credit in WCW, plus the incredibly entertaining "Lost in Cleveland" angle. Cactus Jack by a small margin over Steiner here.

Cactus Jack.

 

[Postman Dave]

Steiner, but Jack is not far behind.

 

[Kushikimi]

Konnan.... why is he on this, didn't like him in WCW, didn't like him on TNA and don't like him on WWC... he's thrown out, then we have Sid, Steiner and Cactus Jack... Steiner before roids was a great in ring talent and had great mic skills, after roids... only great mic skills... he's out. Sid and Jack... Sid wasn't that good in ring performer and wasn't that good on the mic... so he's out. Cactus Jack, as Fuji said, he had a lot of great matches as well as he is a well known name around the world. So my vote goes to Cactus Jack

 

[Gentleman Jake]

Steiner barely

 

[Hoss]

Voting for Sid. He remained over with the crowd from the time he began to the time he quit, for some odd reason. He may not have been the top worker, but his intensity spoke for itself. I'd give Steiner my second, and Jack my third (because he pales in comparison to his ECW and WWF careers), and yeah, Konnan's just a token jobber in this match.